All-Stars
Winner: 5/10 (I get why Amber won, but this was BR's game)
Entertainment: 6/10 (The first couple of episodes are EXCELLENT, then it kind of loses its charm)
Cast: 8/10 (The winner probably shouldn't have been there at all and there were some other more random choices in place of people that didn't want to do it, but I guess everything happens for a reason)
Gameplay: 5/10 (They vote out the winners and the popular people, BR breaks some deals and that's kind of it)

Worlds Apart
Winner: 8/10 (Mike dominated IMO, his competition didn't do a good job of managing the jury, and his other competition was hated)
Entertainment: 5/10 (Starts off good, then gets REALLY ugly and uncomfortable)
Cast: 5/10 (Some messed up people in this cast, but sometimes that messed up part is strangely entertaining)
Gameplay: 5/10 (The blindsides weren't really on power players and the winner wasn't a strategic mastermind or anything)

I feel like Worlds Apart is gonna be that season that people see as terrible as time goes on. I've only liked All-Stars more and more as time goes on, I get why people hate it, but I think enough time has passed that even the cast themselves is (hopefully) over all the stuff that went down.