CI
Winner: 7/10 (IMO, Yul is just a liiiitle overrated. Smart guy, good winner, but not a mastermind or anything)
Entertainment: 6/10 (The underdog run of the Aitus was fun to watch, and there's some entertaining players, but this cast is pretty boring)
Cast: 6/10 (Some extremely popular players, but most of the other people I liked are gone early)
Gameplay: 5/10 (The winner had the Tyler Perry idol, the "big move" of the mutiny turned out to be stupid af)

Exile
Winner: 5/10 (One of a pair of seasons Cirie should've won)
Entertainment: 8/10 (One of the funniest seasons)
Cast: 7/10 (The fact that Shane missed SC and Woo got in........)
Gameplay: 5/10 (Outside of Cirie, it's pretty much about whoever wins the challenge)

Exile is a top 10 season for me and it wins where it matters most, the cast is an extremely entertaining one even with some duds (*cough* Sally, Austin, the astronaut guy, Nick *cough*).