|
SilverKeith
I'm some guy
| Reputation: 16 | Group: | Novice | Posts: | 114 | Joined: | Jun 21, 2018 |
| Post #1: 27th Jun 2018 10:57 PM | |
'sup guys. I won't be as active during most part of the day. Have to do some stuff. I'll be around couple of hours before EOD and also phonepost I guess.
Too bad Henry flipped town. Still stand by the lynch tho. I at least didn't policy lynch him (I don't know the guy) but generally speaking his play wasn't helpful for town and I see it more often from scum who doesn't care or think they can get a free pass based on play style than from town.
Bad thing two town died but was expecting to be more with the amount of players. I was townreading Herm so that sucks, but I would have gone into Timmah today possibly so it isn't a bad vig kill I guess?
Wikey solely deciding the vote is something I dislike in a general sense because it takes away the fun part of the day. Is kinda bastard but not necessarily bad. Good thing is, Wikey /should/ be town because this ability in a mafia player is kind of op lol. Unless someone gave this power to Wikey. Which I kinda doubt because I don't really see a good reason to choose Wikey for this based on yesterday.
Will add more thoughts when I have more free time. I'd have to look into Herm posts and also into the wagons from yesterday. | |
| | |
SilverKeith
I'm some guy
| Reputation: 16 | Group: | Novice | Posts: | 114 | Joined: | Jun 21, 2018 |
| Post #2: 28th Jun 2018 6:21 PM | |
I'm here. Will be around until EOD.
I'm glad there's 700 posts on one hand because that's a lot of content to analyze but on the other the catch up will take me some time. | |
| | |
SilverKeith
I'm some guy
| Reputation: 16 | Group: | Novice | Posts: | 114 | Joined: | Jun 21, 2018 |
| Post #3: 28th Jun 2018 6:54 PM | |
Will write quick thoughts. Won't put a lot of effort into it like last time.
First thing I checked was that most of the post todays were made by BB/Buffy. Then Primate/Mittens/Josh. Of those 5 at least 4 should be town if not all 5. IDK if Buffy can keep up her pace as scum when posting, judging from yesterday I'd had say no but today this looks good. Almost same thing for Mittens. I was already kinda townreading the other 3.
Reactions to stuff on first pages is whatever. I think I dislike Curtis shading onto the Henry lynch but it's whatever seeing how many ppl supported it judging on the likes. If you don't like a lynch then propose a better one next time my dudes.
DR from TV (...Rose?) comment on lynching one of the Henry voters is too blatantly open to come from scum imo, even if it was a jokey comment.
BB being roleblocked is interesting. Him pointing fingers at Christian for that points at BB being town more than Christian being scum imo, lol.I have to say I don't remember Ahoda that much. I think I townread him. Too many new ppl.
Rip Primate.
Has Wikey manifested btw? Oh his name is Mike. No wonder I don't remember anybody named Wikey from yesterday lol.
This is bad had a pop in that was wolfy as fuck. IDK if Wikey being the man for the lynch is a meme or something but hoping in just to say that and having no comments on other stuff is nagl Other ppl have done this so maybe this is like... uhhh... the one that made me finally realize how many ppl were on this stuff. Maybe I'm used to ppl reading into lynch/killing more I guess. Primate is still town for doing so even if I think his conclusions are wrong.
Light townread on Christian intro. Jme has kinda been going down in my reads, maybe an aftereffect of the Henry lynch. Brain has also been kind of... not doing anything helpful from what I've seen.
@Primate, why do you think I'm "pretending to try"? Does such a thing even exist? I think that I'm clearly trying otherwise I wouldn't have played the day like I did yesterday or doing these long catch ups. My play as town is just to try to be 100% honest with my tought process so ppl can /feel?/ if I'm town.
@Mercator no, Mittens isn't my partner. It's not a bad read is just a level 1 read. I thought that Henry was either getting misslynched or vigged at some point and he wasn't helping town from his D1 where I could see a world where I clear Mittens, so Henry>Mittens and also I had more trust in the ppl voting Henry, I stated before that my biggest townreads were Josh and Zach so I choose to vote with them.
@Jackie why do you think BB is scummy? "Not feeling it" Isn't enough for me, sorry!
Buffy giving reads is always nice, as it is anyone giving reads. I don't remember townreading Brian. IDK if he's being scummy but he's not being helpful so I wouldn't townread him. Who the fuck is nav. Those "could be scum" is how I feel about Curtis, less so about Ahoda I feel. I don't feel like I've been townie enough like last game to be her biggest townread, but can't blame her on being right I guess.
Seb post on me looks like a pocket attempt almost, lol. Still townreading him tho.
Buffy looks better from her exchange with BB. She's kinda being overdefensive I think. I'm not sure she should care that much about BB read on her if she were town. I mean, it's whatever. Buffy comment on DR is helpful at least.
Dats it for the first 200. | |
| | |
SilverKeith
I'm some guy
| Reputation: 16 | Group: | Novice | Posts: | 114 | Joined: | Jun 21, 2018 |
| Post #4: 28th Jun 2018 6:55 PM | |
|
|
I'm here. Will be around until EOD.
I'm glad there's 700 posts on one hand because that's a lot of content to analyze but on the other the catch up will take me some time. |
Please ANALyze with a fine tooth comb and report with all the findings color coded and with the entire mafia team outed. Thanks |
How many scum do you (as in you guys) think they are? Do you use usual number of one scum every 3 townies? Do you often play with third parties? | |
| | |
SilverKeith
I'm some guy
| Reputation: 16 | Group: | Novice | Posts: | 114 | Joined: | Jun 21, 2018 |
| Post #5: 28th Jun 2018 7:00 PM | |
That took me like half an hour on 200 pages huhhhh idk if I should do it for the remaining ones when we have 2 hours left.
Would like to know if Mike/Wikey has said anything tho. If he will be around at EOD or something. | |
| | |
SilverKeith
I'm some guy
| Reputation: 16 | Group: | Novice | Posts: | 114 | Joined: | Jun 21, 2018 |
| Post #6: 28th Jun 2018 7:01 PM | |
|
So you love I caught you.
Now you wanna dump silverkeith for me |
You misspelled Empoof. | |
| | |
SilverKeith
I'm some guy
| Reputation: 16 | Group: | Novice | Posts: | 114 | Joined: | Jun 21, 2018 |
| Post #7: 28th Jun 2018 7:07 PM | |
Damn I would have loved to be there to feel the BB pressure onto Buffy. I wrote 2500 words regarding BB in our game btw. So him not being on my ass is great.
3P stuff is interesting. Similar to my homesite I guess, we also have 2 or 3 3P, sometimes a small group in games over 25 ppl.
|
|
Reactions to stuff on first pages is whatever. I think I dislike Curtis shading onto the Henry lynch but it's whatever seeing how many ppl supported it judging on the likes. If you don't like a lynch then propose a better one next time my dudes. |
Exactly what I did! I didn't like the train so I lynched my strongest gut vibe which was Zach who I felt piled onto the easy train at an opportunistic moment
Henry keeps getting lynched D1 every game that he tries to play which sux, hence shading the train |
Well I wasn't aware he keeps getting lynched D1. But, me actually wanting to lynch him D1 says something about that rofl
I think if you really wanted Zach lynched then push harder for it IMO? Zach wasn't getting lynched as long as I was around I think. I mean I can blame you bc you were playing boardgames but you could've voted on a wagon which might caught traction.
Btw there isn't any smiley in the smiles that I like and that is SOMETHING. I love that you have faces to post but IDK which is who so ¿¿?? | |
| | |
SilverKeith
I'm some guy
| Reputation: 16 | Group: | Novice | Posts: | 114 | Joined: | Jun 21, 2018 |
| Post #8: 28th Jun 2018 7:11 PM | |
Ok he gave a list. I'm kinda bothered that he has both Zach and Josh. Idk if I'm missreading both of those or what. I don'n think I am tbh?
Other than that his list seems /alright/ based on what I've seen. I don't remember badger I think? so I'm ISOing in a moment. Mittens is alright in a sense of solving the wagons. Merc and Buffy will have to read more to give a final say but I'm not /against/ them. | |
| | |
SilverKeith
I'm some guy
| Reputation: 16 | Group: | Novice | Posts: | 114 | Joined: | Jun 21, 2018 |
| Post #9: 28th Jun 2018 7:19 PM | |
Buffy readlist is ok. I'd question Curtis/Merc/TIB being kinda high and Zach being low. Her read on ahoda (I usually have him as town but not feeling like it now so he must be scum) comes from... town I think? I kinda have the same read on her lol. It's not a good read to make tbqh.
I don't have any opinion on Vladish or Vance. But other than that I can quickly picture in my mind who is who. Making progress!
Ok onto Seb list, why the fuck does everyone want to lynch Zach lol. I would question Lamps but ¿? | |
| | |
SilverKeith
I'm some guy
| Reputation: 16 | Group: | Novice | Posts: | 114 | Joined: | Jun 21, 2018 |
| Post #10: 28th Jun 2018 7:26 PM | |
Lamps is reading me as scum. Would like some reasoning onto town.
BB flipped on me and now is reading Buffy town and me as scum. Was expecting it tbh.
Lamps 291 feels honest tho. @Lamps, my votes being all over the place at EOD is how I play as town and either one of Buffy or BB can tell you that. I think changing votes forces ppl to give stances and such. How ppl jump onto wagons and the reasons for doing so.
Zach blocked is interesting. Both Zach and BB feel like town to me so... Idk which one comes from scum if one indeeds comee from scum. Maybe Zach? | |
| | |
SilverKeith
I'm some guy
| Reputation: 16 | Group: | Novice | Posts: | 114 | Joined: | Jun 21, 2018 |
| Post #11: 28th Jun 2018 7:35 PM | |
|
Mittens OMGUSing all over me makes me feel I was right to vote him yesterday.
I actually am seeing a SK as scum as well. FOlks brought up the vote jumping but that isn't it- I don't like his excuse for the Henry vote (i.e., Henry's posts weren't "helpful"- what's helpful about anything on D1? It's a joke fest. That's a pretty weak argument for a vote that he likely thinks makes him look bad.
|
|
At this point, I'm leaning town on:
Lamps
Merc
probably BB
Ape (but he's dying anyway) :(
Leaning scum on:
Mittens (I feel he's overreacting like scummittens)
SK (stated above)
Buffy (seems to be defending SK right now)
|
Vladikins opinion on me I dislike. Thing is, it's too simpleminded. Mittens is scum. I tried to "save" Mittens, so I'm scum too. Buffy is townreading me, so she's scum too. I went against Mercator so he must be town. Buffy going against Primate so he must be town. Like, these reads feels like poor associations that comes from scum more often that not.
I don't think D1 should be a jokefest and my posts have clearly showed that also. I want to start clearing townies from the start and anyone who isn't willing to cooperate on that regard, I find it hard to have any mercy on. | |
| | |
SilverKeith
I'm some guy
| Reputation: 16 | Group: | Novice | Posts: | 114 | Joined: | Jun 21, 2018 |
| Post #12: 28th Jun 2018 7:36 PM | |
Oh wow rip Zach. One of my strongest townreads. Not feeling great about that tbh.
Does boc comes and ends day now or do we have the rest of the time to post? | |
| | |
4 Users Viewing (4 Guests) |
|
|