I've kind of already talked about stuff that went well/didn't, but here we go.

Hall of Fame:

-In no particular order-

Wikey: a Town Vanilla who zeroed in on Josh, a member of the Mafia, only voting for him until Josh was out of the game. With his next vote, he hammered the last remaining member of the Mafia to end the game and earn Town the victory. It would have been hella interesting if Wikey had been forced to join up with Josh after going after him so aggressively.

Lamps: The Nexus on Night 2 caused a lot of confusion for Day 3, but ultimately led to an very fun read as everyone tried to figure it out. He used his other actions to protect the Town Watcher, even though it wasn't needed on that night, and gave a day kill to Mittens which led to Mafia Poisoner Josh's death. His reads during the day threads however, were a bit off. But it didn't matter much.

Buffy/Nav: one of them loves being scum, one of them doesn't but they both put in a lot of effort and their enthusiasm was very much appreciated. The Mafia forum would have been deserted if they hadn't been so active, even if they didn't have a lot of time to be around.

Penner: also for being so enthusiastic and catching the Serial Killer red-handed.

Herm: waited to use his actions until he had an idea on who to use them on. Twice, he motivated the Town Doctor, allowing him to protect two people from attacks at night.

Anyone who had fun.

Anyone who read the flavour. :P


Hall of Lame:

-In no particular order-

I have to mention it, even though he thought he'd be protecting a scumbuddy, but if Nav had picked anyone else, Curtis would not have died that night as Ahoda's kill was blocked.

Brian didn't join the Mafia forum until well after the game had started. There was no communication between him and his team. And losing him early due to inactivity or whatever the reason ended up being, hurt the Mafia team badly, especially after losing their roleblocker.

Primate missed the deadline to submit an action one night. Could have made a difference, but probably not. Still, booo. :P

Cavin trying and trying to get Rodney killed, but never using the Strongman's he had at his disposal. They would have either killed Rodney on Night 1 or killed Lamps on Night 2.

Buffy, after Primate outed her as being seen visiting someone, for claiming that her action was unsuccessful. The contradictory information did not help her.

The Mafia not attacking Wikey at night even though Josh suggested it. It could have been a very different game if they had. At least, it'd have lasted a little bit longer. :P


Those are the ones that stood out.


Some other random thoughts:

I enjoyed seeing "Cavin" play. He got the got benefit of the doubt where DS would not have...even though many had figured it out.

I enjoyed Mittens' and others' thoughts on the game in the role PM thread.

I loved how Primate's look-alike sex robot became a topic of conversation lol

I hate making these lists btw.

Primate @ 14/8/2019 12:18

Buffy made both lists

So did you if you had fun playing. ;)