JJ @ 28/11/2018 21:06

Sebclops @ 28/11/2018 21:02 Curtis @ 28/11/2018 18:00 Why Helios why To be fair, Joshie would have been my pick as well He was softclaiming doc. Not that I was sold but I wouldn't have killed him just in case.

I didn't pick up on that. I get what he was trying to say now though, when he said he was the only one visiting you or only visiting you, or whatever he said.

Sebclops @ 28/11/2018 21:07

JJ @ 28/11/2018 18:06 Sebclops @ 28/11/2018 21:02 Curtis @ 28/11/2018 18:00 Why Helios why To be fair, Joshie would have been my pick as well He was softclaiming doc. Not that I was sold but I wouldn't have killed him just in case. I thought that at first. But them Primate said something which made me think he's Doc. And I trusted Primate WAYYYY more than Joshie.

I had the same thought about Primate. Oh gosh, you and me thinking the same.

Mercator @ 28/11/2018 21:11

Well since Helios flipped town, Spider actually went up on my scum list because of the bus-ing

yeah, that is kind of weird. Seems to be the only case of an action not going as intended? At least that we know of.

if Nav is actually going to use the role he claimed he had, Lamps should probably be in there. Maybe Kat. Maybe Spider if we think what happened with the mystery box on Night 1 was down to scum. I've been giving the benefit of the doubt for still being new, but she's catching on pretty quick.

Sebclops @ 28/11/2018 21:50

For the people who are putting in the qualifier of "if Nav is going to use his role" Do you want me to use it or not?

Some of us believe you. Some of us don't. If you use it, all of us will believe you. You have to give us a reason to.

Lynch Tally

Lamps (3/8): Curtis, Zersch, JJ, Herm
Kat (1/8): Herm
Spider (1/8): Ahoda

Curtis @ 28/11/2018 23:24

Nav literally did flee It's too bad Lamps is scum, I'd love to switch

sorry, catching up. Don't know if he used the role or not, I'm assuming he didn't.
I think either of these two are the way to go.

Curtis @ 29/11/2018 13:05

Hey Christian Herm and Zersch you feel like claiming for no real reason or naw I think at least one of you has gotta be scum

not particularly, not at this point anyway.
I'm not scum, nor do I have a killing role.
If I did, Nav would be dead. Maybe not on the first night, but definitely by now. :P

I can see arguments for Lamps as SK. I think it makes most sense for him to go first.
But I can't shake the feeling that Nav might also be. If I recall, he said earlier that finding mafia is top priority. While finding more Mafia would definitely be more helpful, this is certainly something a SK would say.

so Lamps has claimed Third Party, and we know that he's survived an attack. At worst, he's Third Party. :P At best, he's Mafia. That seems like the sure bet, no?

I have to think about the possibilities of what happened last night re: who might have attacked who. I know there was some discussion about this, but I have to think through it myself.

Curtis @ 29/11/2018 15:54

JJ @ 29/11/2018 15:53 Lamps, admit you're SK and vow to kill for town and I'll unlynch you. Yeah do this please Lamps. Then we can all lynch Nav and live happily ever after

I also have no problem with a Nav lynch, as I may have stated on several occasions.
I think he's been stringing us along this whole time. I do appreciate the positive words though. :P

Herm, it's a fake claim, it could very well be a fake name as well.

so with Helios' kill, there should have been 4 attacks in total last night:
1-Josh: killed by Helios
2-Maddie (vig): killed by either Mafia or SK
3-survival (?): attacked by either Mafia, SK, or Vig (Maddie)
---Lamps claimed survival on Night 3, but not last night
---a) he's lying and actually did survive on back to back nights
---b) the person attacked and the person who did the attacking know who survived, and unless Maddie did it, I don't expect the Mafia or SK to claim the kill attempt.
4-blocked kill/no kill?: with only one known instance of a block, it's still a possibility, which makes more sense than someone not killing at this stage of the game. If it was Maddie, we won't know. And if it was Mafia or SK, we won't know. Is there any other explanation? I'd assume a kill would still go through if the attacker also died.

So yeah, that's not very helpful really. lol

But still think Lamps makes the most sense probably.

Lynch Tally

Lamps (3/8): Curtis, Zersch, JJ, Herm, Spider, Primate
Nav (1/8): Curtis, Nav, Primate
Spider (1/8): Ahoda
Herm (1/8): Kat
Kat (0/8): Herm

Nav, why were you lynching yourself?

itsbrianyay @ 29/11/2018 16:25

Curtis @ 29/11/2018 15:19 Brian what would your theory be if I told you I had the exact same role as you but worded slightly differently Wouldn’t that be a little odd Sure yes that would be odd So do you think Mafia had timmah AND someone else who can scan roles??? How does that equate to me being scum

how similar are these roles? Brian said he had a chance to survive? If Curtis' works the same, I think I could believe both to be Town, if they weren't guaranteed to survive death. But since we're missing a couple of Mafia still, that might change things.