Night 1
Mafia sends Vic to kill Ari (blocked by Town RB)
Miko blocks Schrauben
Dadd steals vote from Vern
Herm strongman kills nobody
Brian not using
im317 not using
Patrick investigates Herm (guilty)
Badger vig kills Redster (Vanilla)
Bryce tracks Merc. (You see your target visit nobody.)
Buffy protects Buffy.
Canuck blocks Vic
Free Candy gives gun to nobody
Ari 50/50 protects Ari.
Rose motion detects Buffy (You see that a night action was performed on your target)
Primate gives hammer to nobody.
Schrauben bodyguards Ahoda
Chris not using his action

Night 2
Mafia sends Vic to kill Rose
Miko blocks Curtis
Dadd protects Miko
Herm strongman kills nobody
Brian not using
im317 not using
Patrick investigates Miko (guilty)
Badger vig kills Canuck
Bryce tracks Badger (You see your target visit Canuck)
Canuck blocks Angi
Free Candy gives gun to nobody
Ari 50/50 protects Merc
Rose motion detects Brian
Primate gives hammer to JC
Schrauben bodyguards Merc.
Chris no action

Night 3
Mafia sends Vic to kill Patrick
Dadd redirects Badger To Primate
Herm strongman kills nobody
Brian not using
im317 not using
Patrick investigates Vernon (Not Guilty)
Badger vig kills Dadd (redirected to Primate)
Bryce tracks Badger (You see your target visit Primate)
Free Candy gives gun to Rob
Ari 50/50 protects Patrick
Schrauben bodyguards Patrick (dies in place of Patrick)
Chris no action submitted

Night 4
Mafia sends Vic to kill Patrick
Herm strongman kills nobody
Brian recruits Timmah (Timmah becomes Sheriff and joins Cult)
im317 not using
Patrick investigates Brian (guilty)
Badger vig kills Free Candy
Bryce tracks Brian (You see your target visit Timmah)
Ari 50/50 protects Patrick (fails)

Night 5
Mafia sends Vic to kill Bryce
Herm strongman kills nobody
Brian not using
im317 not using
Timmah investigate JC (not guilty)
Badger vig kills Ahoda
Bryce tracks Timmah (You see your target visit JC)
Ari 50/50 protects Bryce (successful)

Night 6
Mafia sends Herm to kill Timmah
Herm strongman kills Timmah
Brian not using
im317 not using
Timmah investigates Curtis (no result on account of dying)
Bryce tracks Curtis (You see your target visit nobody)
Ari 50/50 protects Bryce

Night 7
Mafia sends Vic to kill Bryce (Bryce "dies" but joins Cult)
im317 recruits Mafia's intended kill target (Bryce)
Bryce tracks im317 (You see your target visit nobody)
Ari 50/50 protects Ari

Night 8
Mafia sends Vic to kill Bryce
Bryce tracks Vic (would have seen target visiting nobody)
Ari 50/50 protects Ari

Night 9
Mafia sends Vic to kill Vernon

CULT:
http://s15.zetaboards.com/T1WDC/index/

MAFIA:
http://s15.zetaboards.com/TWDM/index/

This is the list that Lamps and I came up with. I may add to add it as I remember more, but this is what stands out most right now.

Let's get the bad out of the way.

HoL

wait wat? for making me modkill poor Rosita, meaning that the night phases would have only one kill per night after Badger was taken out.

Titan for revenge killing Buffy for personal reasons. Losing the Town Doctor would normally be a big deal. Luckily, there were some other protective roles out there. But losing Buffy that early, not my favourite thing that happened.

JC's day kill. I don't think killing Nofo was a waste, but there were better options, such as Miko and Herm, who Patrick had received guilty results on.

the Ari lynch was just bad.

Curtis' Day 10 Angi lynch. It was risky to put a vote on anyone knowing that scum could jump right on it and end the day. Being a Townie, I would want someone I suspected to be scum to be the first vote on Angi.

Town in general for letting so many question marks slide by...mostly Herm's Miller claim and "Immunity from kills". Also not even thinking about im317 claiming Vic to be scum based on im317's role.

Mafia occasionally not thinking things through and sometimes backing themselves into a corner. The Day 2 fiasco comes to mind as well as the plan to get Jayadamo lynched.

Cult for waiting to use their actions and then completely flopping, with all 4 members being either lynched or killed back to back to back to back.

Christian screwing up the end of day lynch and killing Jayadamo when the vote actually tied. That's what I get for trying to get the end of the day up immediately. I missed a last second vote.



HoF

Patrick investigating and getting guilty results on Herm and Miko the first 2 nights. He would have gotten a guilty result on Brian as well if Patrick had not been killed the night he was.

Mafia redirecting Badger's vig kill on Dadd, which bought him a little bit more time.

Mafia's very risky strategy of throwing almost all of their members under the bus. I kept waiting for Vic and Herm to turn on each other.

Vernon for lasting longer than a day.

Vic's activity. Although I thought he would eventually slip up somewhere and be caught in a lie for talking way too much :P, many believed him to be Town, which could be down to his defensive and above the radar gameplay.

Schrauben saving Patrick and buying him an extra night.

Ari saving Bryce.

The first time someone flipped as Cult. Changed the game a little, but it was still fun to see that element confirmed to players, after being speculated about for a while.

Herm's Miller claim and his awareness in general, he figured out that Badger was likely the Vigilante. Major asset to the Mafia team.

Curtis for finally figuring things out, although it was too late.

A number of people for pegging certain peeps as scum. I can't remember exactly, but I'm going to name Ari, im317 and Ahoda here.

Lamps for helping make this game as balanced as it was and running through various scenarios with me.

These were the things that stood out to us (ie. JC's daykill).

Mafia does gets HoL for some of things they did. Mafia gets HoF for some of things they did.

Curtis didn't get HoL, but his vote on the last day did. ;) I know it wasn't his fault, but that's when the game truly ended.

Vernon, you got HoF for one reason only. :P

Patrick @ 29/1/2016 20:07

Back to back HoF's My next game ruining screw up is inevitable. Just in time for ATTWS.

only if you don't get cop.

BTW, I laughed that Bryce was Tracker and Patrick was Cop and Rose had a watching ability just like the previous game.

im317 @ 29/1/2016 23:28

Christian @ 29/1/2016 20:25 Patrick @ 29/1/2016 20:07 Back to back HoF's My next game ruining screw up is inevitable. Just in time for ATTWS. only if you don't get cop. BTW, I laughed that Bryce was Tracker and Patrick was Cop and Rose had a watching ability just like the previous game. have you forgotten that there are no cops in ATTWS?

yes. I only played in one.

Buffy @ 30/1/2016 16:19

Which one? *snap*

you mean *snaps photo*?