Tastemaker Paul/Oyster Hunter/Total Mastery/Gold Grill Shawty would all make really interesting roles.

This is how I pictured the roles when I picked them:

Tastemaker Paul, sounds like some kind of cannibal.
Oyster Hunter, seafood is very delicious (lobsters, shrimp, oysters) and the hunt is on for the pearl.
Total Mastery, sounds like a role that can learn every role in the game.
Gold Grill Shawty, joker pick.