Im317, what did you do last night?

I was a bit surprised about Buffy's death.

We got to hear from im317 on this.

Anyway, who is left?

We got:

Herm: Town obviously
im317: Town Vigilante
JC: Town (silenced Day 2, most likely by Mafia)

Timmah: Lynched Ari before it was cool
Curtis: Lynched Ari before it was cool
Wikey: Lynched Ari after im317 showed up
Schrauben: -"-
Canuck: -"-

Dylan: Could be scum, initially "seemed" to be against an Ari lynch
Henry: Not sure
Redster: Where is he? Could be scum.
Jayadamo: -"-

I'm obviously town from my own pov, but to answer your question. Almost never, lol.

Maybe a SK used coal to kill Brian and Buffy?

I personally think there's only one mafia, I'd think that a third party SK could be responsible for the extra deaths.

im317 @ 4/11/2015 5:43

i just confirmed that Christian did not forget to tell me i was blocked. im guessing i was redirected in some way.

Redirected to Buffy possibly.

I think Buffy's roleblock was redirected over to someone.

Maybe they also went for Ahoda?

Well, im317's confusion what happened to his kill confuses me for the moment.

Why mafia didn't kill any of the power roles Night 2 is a mystery, but their attack was stopped Night 3 and Night 4 the roleblocker and the twins all died so there's that.

Timmah made a good point about the redirector.

Timmah

I thought it was clear that any redirector was not mafia. Otherwise we'd have seen 317 redirected previously or even Buffy. Trying to float this just makes you look worse...

If there's a mafia redirector out there then why didn't they bother to redirect the power roles on night 3 when Ari was blocked by Buffy and im317 killed Chris? If the redirector is town then he should've spoken up.

Makes me think there's no redirector.

Is it possible the mafia could've just forgotten to send in a kill Night 2?

I'd really like to find out who im317 targeted last night, but I guess it's worth waiting for since he wanted to see if that person said anything first.

Jayadamo, Redster, Henry and Canuck all have light evidence that they could be town, I'll go through what I think about them in a short moment.

There should be 2-3 mafia left which is why I'm not ruling out anyone who lynched Ari yesterday, except for Timmah and probably Curtis.

Oh and JC obviously.

Day 1

Redster: Lynched Shadow. Realized he wasn't playing. Lynched Timmah, ending up as the third vote on his train.
Henry: Started the game by beheading Badger for confusing Spider Man and Batman. Placed a lynch vote on Vernon almost twelve hours after Angi placed a joke lynch on him, building it up to two lynch votes on an imaginary player. Once he realized Vernon was imaginary, he placed the final lynch vote on Free Candy.
Canuck: Quoting Henry's post, he also lynched Vernon. If anyone of them were scum they placed lynch votes on a player that wasn't playing started by a fellow scum member from their team almost 12 hours earlier, if there's two scum on that train their communication and observation skills as scum are really bad. He then went on to lynch Redster.
Jayadamo: Ari was the first person to lynch him on Day 1 for showing up late, eventually scored two more lynch votes. He first lynched Nobert to welcome him back to the game, then switched to Free Candy for preservation.
Schrauben: Placed the first lynch vote on Free Candy.

Day 2

Redster: He was roleblocked by Buffy Night 1 and announced this in his third post of the day. Agreed with Timmah's post, but also said that he looked bad for wanting to crucify anyone on the lynch train that built on him Day 1 and Wikey and said he wanted to hear more from him.
Henry: No posts.
Canuck: Lynched JC and later explained that he followed Timmah's reasoning for lynching him. Once he realized JC had been silenced, he switched to Henry.
Jayadamo: He started Day 2 by saying he was comfortable with lynching JC, Buffy, Wikey and Redster from a list, possibly Timmah's list. Lynched Buffy and argued that if she's scum, Wikey's also likely scum. When im317 speculated that JC could've made up being silenced, Jayadamo argued against him. Later on he said, in response to Buffy:

Spoiler	+
Jay Meaning you two are working well together to move from the first "reason" someone is scum that led to u leading in votes to the next "reason" someone is scum. I believe it is safe to say that you and im317 and wikey and imnumbers aren't aligned.

I assume he felt that im317 and Buffy were not aligned since they tried to lynch each other, but he said he had a feeling that Wikey was protecting Buffy.
Schrauben: He was lynched by me and told me he wasn't scum. This is when he started to get busy with IRL stuff.

Day 3

Redster: No posts.
Henry: Mourned spaghetti girl. Then asked a reason to lynch either JC, Rose or Buffy. He eventually went for Buffy after quoting one of my posts.
Canuck: Agreed that a Chris or Buffy lynch could give us info. Also said that he decides to believe im317's claim and JC being silenced for now, although he also speculated alternatives if they were scum/lying because no one else had seems to have been silenced and speculated that im317 could've made a ballsy move to draw out other town power roles. Lynched Rose and said that if she's lying, then we should lynch Buffy the day after. I assume he drew the conclusion that Buffy blocked Rose, which stopped the mafia kill. Believed that Rose's claim was convenient, but did not want to lynch her and argued his reasons why. After getting scum vibes from me and Henry, he lynched me.
Jayadamo: 1 post, a lynch on Buffy.
Schrauben: No posts.

Day 4

Redster: No posts.
Henry: He doesn't seem to know what to do this day, starts by lynching JC. He thinks Ari and JC are scum together. Sleepwalks into the thread at the end.
Canuck: Talks and contributes with a lot of thoughts, speculated about the kills. He said that JC was the only one he felt was definitely town at this point (he argued his reasons to Wikey, who argued the opposite at the time), then agreed that it could be a good idea to lynch an inactive. He lynched Redster. He then switched to Schrauben. He argued even more that the way JC drew attention to himself with the whole "silenced" thing made him think he was probably telling the truth. Still has a scum vibe on Henry, once im317 showed up to lynch Ari he unlynched Schrauben and joined in on the fun.
Jayadamo: No posts.
Schrauben: He showed up and explained why he hadn't been around, said he was suspicious of Ari, Wikey and Curtis the most. Showed up before im317 showed up, Ari fluctuated between 1-2 lynch votes at this point. He lynched Wikey. He also argued that a mafia redirector does not seem likely, since im317's kill went through to Chris on Night 3. Speculates about the twins for a bit, then joins in and lynches Ari.

Wikey @ 4/11/2015 18:01

Redster @ 4/11/2015 11:41 I don't see why he is holding back his target. Sounds like a scummy thing to do, so we won't be able to figure out exactly what happened. Seems like it would benefit us to know who he targeted. Or am I missing something? Yeah, it would also benefit scum to know who he targeted last night. He's doing the right thing by not saying anything, and I find it scummy you are calling for him to reveal a name.

Ah, good point I guess.