LOTR - So good. I saw it twice in the theaters
Finding Nemo - A classic in my house. Kids watch it all the time
Lost in Translation - Was pretty good. Not sure I liked it as much as everyone else though
Kill Bill - Many didn't like it but I did. Liked this one better than the second.
The Last Samurai - Meh
PotC - Thought it was really good. Had no expectations upon initial watch and really enjoyed it.
Big Fish - Really good needs a rewatch
Master and Commander - snoozefest
X2 - Just as good as the first. Another one a lot of people didn't care for but I thought it was excellent.

AND from the others list:

The Matrix Reloaded - meh. high expectations but just wasn't as good as the first. Some scenes were good but a disappointment
The Matrix Revolutions - lol don't get me started on this one
Hulk- straight garbage
Daredevil - see above
Bruce Almighty - pretty good 1 time watch. not carey's best but not horrible.