I think you should wait for Penner to out his info, before using it.

It may have been stupid to give it to Mittens, but I think I got what he was up to the last few days and think I know his role. I won’t claim for him though lol like that is unnecessary.

Also with Penner and Farlig as top 2 scum targets, giving them a gift coulda been a waste. Then third best option for town has to be Cody or Mittens, imo.

I think it makes sense to take the vengeful claim out this way. My other top scum reads are probably Herm and Josh. Mayyybe Timmah or Nav.

Btw to me it looks like there is no even night vig. There’s no sign of them at all.

You’re not convincing me of your read on Cody anyway :p

Cody @ 12/8/2019 6:02

Lamps. I trust you. How are you feeling about Josh and herm. And what about TiBs vengeful claim. I think I mainly believe it bc ToB didn’t like NEED to claim. Ya know? I would expect his Scum forum to be helping him if he was that busy. And like, he didn’t need to but he just did so I think I believe it.

I think we have seen scum TIB this game. Of course he says he is busy, but I don’t believe it. I don’t fancy trying out that claim, so I wouldn’t be against having him daykilled.

Josh didn’t come across as scum to me D3, but he is kind of left by process of elimination.

Herm yeah uhm kind of very scummy, but it was funny what he did with his lynch vote yesterday. It made him look slightly better imo. Also process of elimination.

We should not forget Wikey btw. He looks townish to me, but there is no proof of it and his voting record isn’t the best.

I hope Penner’s info will be good because there are too many uncertainties right now.

I guess we have to wait til Penner and Mittens wake up before this day really begins...

Alive (11)

Towniest
2. Lamps ~ nexus blabla
9. Penner ~ tracker confirmado

Townishish
15. Mittens ~ has atomic bomb
12. Cody ~ visiting role, not confirmed

Middle tier
14. Wikey ~ VT not confirmed
18. Timmah ~ idk?
6. Nav ~ hinted at role très importante

Scumishish
1. TIB ~ Quiet TIB = scum TIB
13. Josh ~ scummy?
8. Herm ~ scummy?

Didn't know was in the game
10. im317 ~ only reason he is seen as town is Curtis' vote?

IM317 said this yesterday: "just want to point out that the hider did not die by hiding behind scum. now on to post 351"

There was not even a "you die if you hide behind scum" condition in Rodney's role. Is that why you said that IM?

wikeyb9m3bek @ 12/8/2019 10:49

Lamps @ 12/8/2019 0:25 We should not forget Wikey btw. He looks townish to me, but there is no proof of it and his voting record isn’t the best. My voting record isn't the best? What are you basing that on? I've voted Josh practically every day and we don't know his alignment. That aside, I was an early suspect of Buffy, and I think my reads have been decent, albeit a bit erratic at times. I don't mind you not ruling me out, it's good to err on the side of caution, but there's nothing wrong with my voting record.

Well you don't know for sure, just like I don't know for sure, whether your voting record isn't the best, or whether nothing is wrong with it. As it stands though, you did not vote Brian or Buffy, so there are other, more suspicious people, with better voting records.

I'm interested to see Josh flip though, yeahh.

Thisisbad @ 12/8/2019 10:56

I don't know what to tell you about actually being busy this time. I had a 16 hour day and a 14 hour day. But if you want to go by my meta of being quiet, i also never claim when scum either. I came out with my claim because i wasn't going to have much time. Id also like to again point out i called brian and buffy scum day 2. And i don't bus scummates. But you can pick which part you want to believe.

Some good points imo.

The bomb came from a town source, it's not sabotaged (unless there is hidden text involved). Since we have not seen another day kill ability, I think it is safe to use. Had there been another day kill item then I would have been more skeptical as then usually one is real and the other is bad.

wikeyb9m3bek @ 12/8/2019 11:34

Lamps @ 12/8/2019 5:29 The bomb came from a town source, it's not sabotaged (unless there is hidden text involved). Since we have not seen another day kill ability, I think it is safe to use. Had there been another day kill item then I would have been more skeptical as then usually one is real and the other is bad. How do we know it came from town again? I must have missed that

Because I'm town..

Nav who did you try to target N2?