Well I visited Perry last night and now he's lynching me, but he knows I'm town so I don't understand why he would lynch me. He also had the mafia save him over Ari so.

##Lynch Perry

Idk if people can have the same roles in Mafia. The role Patrick described yesterday is the same as mine, however given that we're both towns I can see us both having that role.

Boc was blocking Rob and when Boc died we had a kill so,

##Lynch Rob

I don't care if he was confirmed town all those nights ago. This is a doctor who mafia where up can be down and diet coke can be Everclear. I really would not be surprised if his role changed. Plus Shawn lynched him yesterday and now Shawn's dead.

Jack Frobst @ 26/12/2013 0:51

Right, Colby, because I'd be stupid enough to kill the guy who tried lynching me. It's pretty obvious that whoever's left knows that I was a lynch candidate yesterday so they probably offed Shawn just to make me look suspicious. It's the oldest trick in the book, dude.

Oh trust me, that thought ran through my head, but I also wouldn't be surprised if you were the last Mafia and killed Shawn as a means to use reverse psychology at the lynch. I also just don't understand how this game was suppose to be over and now it's dragging out. The vibe I got when there was suspicion on you a couple days ago was that had you died the game would be over.

Jack Frobst @ 26/12/2013 1:00

So, let me get this straight. It's more likely to you that I'm playing some bizarre reverse-psychology BS than that the person who literally roleclaimed the same ability as you is lying? Seriously, dude.

When you're told you're town and all you do is visit a player at night then yes I can see us having the same role. Bottom line you can't have a town full of doctors and cops. Otherwise the Mafia would never win because the town would have a means of saving themselves and getting information like clockwork. There's got to be people in there that have filler roles. You've been playing the victim role since you were revived and that's another reason I think you're feeding us BS and trying to use reverse psychology.

Jack Frobst @ 26/12/2013 1:11

There are a really staggering number of town roles, it's pretty unrealistic to expect that Samm just kind of ran out of them and gave two people the same one.

This is my first mafia game. I don't really expect there to be many town roles because there's only so much a town can do that wouldn't overpower a mafia. Ive had other people (Buffy days ago) confirm I visited them as town so if you want to lynch someone, then lynch Patrick since he hasn't been confirmed by anyone. Lynching me to me just seems like vengeance and makes me all the more suspicious of you.

Jack Frobst @ 26/12/2013 1:24

Well, justifying your roleclaim with testimony from a confirmed mafia isn't really that helpful, and I already explained my reasons for lynching you. Vengeance has nothing to do with it. It doesn't make sense that you'd just randomly assume you had the same role instead of going after Patrick for the dual roleclaim. Most townies wouldn't just pass that sort of thing off, and the only sort of person who'd want that kind of thing swept under the rug is someone who has something to hide.

I told you the only reason I pass it off is because it's such a simple role I can see multiple people having it. It's my first game so it's not like I know better. The only reason I bring up vengeance is because it seems like everyone who speaks out against you gets lynched or killed, and I'm the last person who is suspicious if you. I have nothing to hide and have been confirmed by Perry and Animal as well. Feel free to leave your lynch on me but you are for sure wasting a day and dragging the game out even longer. The other reason I'm suspicious of you is because Shawn and Boc seemed to be pretty reliable sources and they were both suspicious of you.

Animal @ 26/12/2013 2:36

Colby @ 26/12/2013 0:49 Well I visited Perry last night and now he's lynching me, but he knows I'm town so I don't understand why he would lynch me. He also had the mafia save him over Ari so. ##Lynch Perry Wait, what were your results for Perry last night?

I don't get any information about people unless they aren't home. They are just told I'm town if they are home. Of the people still alive I've also visited Justin, Paco, and Vic so they can vouch for me that I'm town.

Role: Friendly Neighbour
Role Description: Every night you may visit a player, they will be told that you are town.

Santa Smurf @ 26/12/2013 7:23

Colby @ 26/12/2013 2:31 Animal @ 26/12/2013 2:36 Colby @ 26/12/2013 0:49 Well I visited Perry last night and now he's lynching me, but he knows I'm town so I don't understand why he would lynch me. He also had the mafia save him over Ari so. ##Lynch Perry Wait, what were your results for Perry last night? I don't get any information about people unless they aren't home. They are just told I'm town if they are home. Of the people still alive I've also visited Justin, Paco, and Vic so they can vouch for me that I'm town. So let me get this straight....If you get no information that means they're home, otherwise you are told they are out?

I haven't been told anything except in the case of Animal. When I visited him, Samm told me he wasn't there. I visited Buffy the first night and wasn't told anything about her. (And she turned up Mafia) I'm pretty sure it was only applicable to Animal since he left the universe so there's no way he would have been home at all through the night. If they have a role and come home afterwards, they still get told I'm town. In Animals case, there was no way for me to visit him and him to know I was town since he was gone the entire night. That's probably the only reason I got the info that he wasn't there.