Spot 1: Rory - Okay, he's charged with murder, but he's the only one who can navigate. He has to be on there.

Spot 2: Carly - A nurse is invaluable, and given she has already proved herself useful, she is a must have.

Spot 3: Richard - He's been in tough situations, and his sense of humour and courage will be important to maintain morale.

Spot 4: Brett - Won't someone think of the children?!

Spot 5: Mary - She's young, and I guess she could help with Brett

Spot 6: Amy - It'd be preferable not to leave her and Russ's children orphans.

Spot 7: Marcus - May be useful for morale purposes, and he's young.

Spot 8: Jimmy - Young, plus he's probably reasonably smart

Spot 9: Matthew - If Matthew has the only source of food, then I guess he has to be let on board. But tbh, I can't guarantee he wouldn't be thrown overboard after handing it over. The last thing you need in this situation is a selfish shit who is unwilling to cooperate. Plus, when we've got Rory on board too, that could be a dangerous combination.

I dunno, if we already have some kind of food supplies I'd probably leave Matthew behind, and throw Russ or Dom in there