Login | Register Login: Skin: Go To Top Lock User Bar
Logo
Page: 1 2
Day 5
 
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #1: 21st Jun 2015 3:39 AM 
Yes hello
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #2: 21st Jun 2015 4:58 AM 
I see quite a lot of people cottoned on to Walk. I think those suspicions are worth pursuing. I found the Cake/Walk exchanges on Day 2 a bit forced.

Cake Day 2
Lol overdeffensive, you praise me and agree with me then you are like idk.

Tricks is mafia.

Walk Day 2
You literally just called Tricks mafia and then just flat out said you weren't overdefensive. You are being overdefensive and yes, I believe you are Mafia. I've seen you play Mafia before, and I know what to expect. If you were even a slight inch of town you wouldn't be throwing out names to lynch in every post

It seemed odd to me that Walk would try to lynch Cake so badly based on sketchy meta reasoning. It felt forced, like he was trying too hard to blend in. The Cake/Walk feud felt forced by both parties to me though. Funny how it hasn't surfaced again since. If I was to lynch either of them though, it would obviously have to be Walk. The evidence against him has been mounting.

There was also periods during both day 2 and 3 were several people pushed for random inactives. It struck me as suspicious that votes came in for completely different inactives within short succession of each other, rather than people gathering on one.

The worst offenders to me are:

Timmah, BadgerMcgeaver, Colby, and Daniel

It is suspicious because from a town perspective, you want a concrete idea of who is going to get lynched at the end of the day, and so if you see a particular inactive been targeted, and your leaning towards getting rid of one too, your tendency is to hop on the train. not start a separate one on someone else. But from a mafia point of view, you'd try to avoid jumping on a train because you wouldn't want to attract attention. Willing to bet at least one of the above listed players are scum.

Colby aroused my suspicions for something else.

Colby
I don't work with Angi. I'm loling that people think I'm automatically a stabilizer because I don't want to lynch her]. Do y'all really think I would come into this thread after Angi already had 8 lynch votes on her and defend her if I was her ally? There's obviously no hope for her at this point. If I were her ally, I would have hopped on the wagon too. I don't want to lynch her because I believe Buffy isn't to be trusted, and I'm standing by that regardless of if Angi is a stabilizer or not.

By his own admission Angi was a goner at this point, and could be a stabilizer, but that doesn't matter because he doesn't trust Buffy. Reading what went down yesterday, I really don't get why anybody mistrusted Buffy. It makes no sense to me at all. Here is what I think Colby was doing. I think he defended Angi a little too hard, realized he couldn't join the lynch train without looking even worse, and tried to rectify it with this bullshit quoted above. The amount of times he says 'If I were her ally I wouldn't do this or that' demonstrates that actually, he just might.
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #3: 21st Jun 2015 4:59 AM 
I think there is a good case to be made for either a Colby or Walk lynch today.

##Lynch Walk

Walk is the best choice though.
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #4: 21st Jun 2015 2:22 PM 
I would say Colby is the better option, but it leaves this annoying Walk/Cake thing unresolved yet another day.

Of course, we have a 100% certain lynch in Ari if we so wish.

As far as I can see he didn't die, his role was revealed, that's all.
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #5: 21st Jun 2015 2:26 PM 
Buffy @ 21/6/2015 15:06
You're a nasty little person and I don't like you at all, and you basically can't pass up responding to anything I say.

Gee Buffy, a little extreme don't you think?
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #6: 21st Jun 2015 2:26 PM 
Buffy @ 21/6/2015 15:23
Ari died a couple days ago.

Ah, silly me
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #7: 21st Jun 2015 2:51 PM 
CherryBerry @ 21/6/2015 15:37
Wikey @ 21/6/2015 15:22
I would say Colby is the better option, but it leaves this annoying Walk/Cake thing unresolved yet another day.

Of course, we have a 100% certain lynch in Ari if we so wish.

As far as I can see he didn't die, his role was revealed, that's all.

Where do you fall on Cake v. Walk, Wikey?

Walk. By quite a margin!
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #8: 21st Jun 2015 5:15 PM 
Timmah @ 21/6/2015 16:49
I'm going to lynch cake for now. The reasons are mostly stated above, but I also have a hard time believing that we have all these town roles that prevent children from visiting them. Why would townies need to prevent other townies from visiting them?

If I missed a bad guy with a similar flip then someone point out my error and I'll fix my misconception.

Other people I could possibly be talked into lynching instead, in order: Shawn, Colby, boc.

I thought you read me as scum? Yet you don't consider me a candidate for lynching?
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #9: 21st Jun 2015 5:15 PM 
Lynching anyone other than Walk or Colby today is sheer lunacy.

 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #10: 21st Jun 2015 5:37 PM 
I can only assume those avoiding lynching one of the two are scum.
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #11: 21st Jun 2015 6:12 PM 
We shouldn't lynch someone who is very likely scum, so let's just choose someone who we have no evidence on instead?
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #12: 21st Jun 2015 6:27 PM 
Two too many lynches on Cake for me. The mere reluctance to get either of the Colby or Walk trains going speaks volumes to me.

##Unlynch
##Lynch Colby
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #13: 21st Jun 2015 6:29 PM 
Time to prove you are indeed town CherryBerry, as the message says.

Get off that silly Shawn train and join the winning side.
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #14: 21st Jun 2015 6:47 PM 
Timmah @ 21/6/2015 19:43
Are my thoughts not valid just because you say so?

Yes
 
   
wikey
User Avatar
10000 Rats
Member Rank
Offline Marker
Reputation: 135
Group:Overlord
Posts:10,641
Joined:Jun 25, 2012
Post #15: 21st Jun 2015 6:47 PM 
SPEAK COLBY
 
   
3 Users Viewing (3 Guests)
  32. BYOR Mafia II  
 
Hosted by N-Dimension Forums.
Create your own free forum today

Mobile Version | Mobile Settings | Report this Forum | Terms of Service