##Lynch Cuhraig

Honestly, it bothers me that he tried to lynch me yesterday. Day 1 sillies is not a good enough excuse, it came across as very scummy indeed.

A lot of people defending Craig right now!

The reluctance to question him by a select few individuals, and even to go as far as say they don't think he is scum at all is troubling.

Reading back, when Craig initially lynched me, it came off as a joke.

Craig

##Lynch Wikey he's already won once! How long must we let his tyrany linger? I think we need a blindside before the merge or else he'll win this game, you guys. Plus he doesn't even do any work around camp! (I'll switch it up if he shows). (Also thanks for the list Rose, appreesh)

Then when Buffy counter lynched him he got very defensive.

Craig

Buffy Wikey's never a no show. Is Moose your scumbuddy? ##lynch Craig I voted for Wikey before a single person voted moose. Also this is my first non-alias game. I have no idea if Wikey is never a no show or not. BUFFY YOUR LOGIC!?

Moose @ 18/12/2014 17:15

I'de okay with a Craig lynch, I'm just worried about what if we're wrong? I think I'll wait to see if there are any inactives near the end and then go for that.

Why??

Can I just say, lynching Cuhraig is a fucking stupid idea.

I don't think Craig is scum, I just wanted to test the waters before I activated my role.

There is no basis for lynching Cuhraig. Sure, he could be scum, but so could anybody.

I tried to see if anybody would go along with my lynch, since the reasoning was rubbish. Kimmy did. And Moose was toying with the idea! Anybody who called out how retarded the lynch was looks good right now too.

I wouldn't be against a Kimmy or Moose lynch right now!

I can assure you all I am town!

I would advise everyone not to let me influence their decisions too much. I have been known to get things wrong many a time.

That said, I feel that my test lynch on Cuhraig makes Kimmy and Moose look a bit scummy, particularly the former. Hopping on that train under my ridiculous reasoning suggests that Kimmy might have been trying to blend in and look like she was thinking about things.

But if she was thinking about what she was doing, she would probably come to the conclusion that the lynch was silly.

It isn't really much to go off, but it is better than nothing and we need to generate discussion if we are going to stand a chance of catching people out.

@Lamps:

I think you can argue for both triggering early and triggering late.

Saving a tree stump until late game brings up the possibility that all the scrutiny you came under during the game up to that point can be used as evidence against players.

But you run the risk of dying and losing it completely!

I at least waited a day and tried to make garner some intel before I triggered it. Granted, I wish I got more.

Lamps @ 18/12/2014 19:27

Yeah I get that you risk being killed at night, but now you basically killed yourself. All that's here is your voice, but not the number.

It's nice to see you hold my voice in such high regard Lamps!