San Juan Del Sur


Rate the season 1-10 on the winner
Natalie 10/10. Great female winner. An edit you rarely see given to one. Her move with the idol at F5 and playing straight to the Jury was gr8.

Rate the season 1-10 on entertainment
6/10. There were lots of blindsides and moves but there was a lack of connection to this cast which brought down the entertainment.

Rate the season 1-10 on the cast overall
4/10. As I said above there was a lack of connection to the cast. Lots and lots of unlikeable people. (Alec, Baylor, John, Dale. Somewhat Drew/Kelley/Wes/Julie for me) I liked Natalie and Jaclyn and the fact they were f2 propels this season for me.

Rate the season 1-10 on gameplay
8/10. There were a lot of shifts. John's blindside. Jeremy's crazy blindside. Keith's "stick to the plan" that ruined a blindside. Wes idoled out. Jon blindsided. Baylor's elimination. One would think it would be an instant top season ~~~ but it all goes back to the cast.



Australia


Rate the season 1-10 on the winner
6/10. The game was still forming in season 2 sooo ya. Tina did a good job socially with everyone.

Rate the season 1-10 on entertainment
7/10. It was a fun season for it's time.

Rate the season 1-10 on the cast overall
7/10. A lot of people were brought back from this for a reason. The highest ratings the show ever got so it forced the players to become big characters

Rate the season 1-10 on gameplay
6/10. Lots of decisions were emotional.



I voted San Juan Del Sur. I prefer new school in this instance.

I mean I consider myself a die-hard survivor fan for seasons I've watched. I basically know them inside out. ~Some~ of the older seasons bore me though which is why I haven't bothered watching them. (Africa/Thailand) Does not help that I know a lot about boot orders because of ORGs etc. I might try and watch Marquesas sooon though.