I'm looking at Simpleton right now for this post:

I'm not lynching someone just for being inactive. As town last game I got the same treatment. It really doesn't grant us the most info since everyone will say LOL inactive so votes cast vs votes not cast would be a long shot to get info. Granted I am a supporter of every lynch and kill gives us more info but I'm not fond on d1 lynches in any format.

Didn't like it then and I still don't like it now. The contradiction of not lynching D1 but "a supporter of every lynch and kill" really sounds scummy. Plus, the wagon forming at the time was for FF and it makes sense for at least some mafia to stay off it.

##lynch Simpleton

Simplton @ 9/12/2013 7:28

But anyway as a real defense why would I draw so much attention to myself as mafia? Why would I not just sit in the background and lynch FF for the same reason and just play it cool for now? Blowing up on town for making a move which I don't agree with isn't a very smart play as mafia.

I actually don't agree with this. I'm of the opinion that mafia would not "sit in the background and lynch FF" rather, they would just sit in the background. Unless I'm not understanding plurality, FF would have been the likely lynch since before your original D1 post. For me, it makes more sense that mafia would simply not vote and draw suspicion onto the bandwagon.

Of course, I have ulterior motives as I was one of the bandwagoners and I'm town.

Also, to add, a vote is a record we can track to nab mafia. The votes on D1 will mean a lot more in a few days, and by people not voting, I believe they are hampering town by not contributing to the evidence pool.

Hm. Well, I think each role reveal here has been extraordinarily useless -- and quite honestly, both of my reads on Ari + Perry are town, albeit dumb town.

That said, I agree that Ari's role seems more scummy... I dunno. I don't feel confident on either, and I'd like to look back at Simpleton + Greenday tomorrow.

#lynch Ari