Ok so I'm pretty drunk and read through this and drrr surviving is suspicious as fuck with the healer roles being outed as stated. I'm not going to lynch because I'm not in the right state of mind to make a decision right now but I'll keep checking in!

Tim you are an idiot just like Quentin how fitting (:

I didn't really read through the flavor thoroughly but could Dylan have been killer because he was recruited? Or is that not possible? I guess that makes little sense but IDK

*****killed

Tim @ 12/4/2014 23:52

Vic @ 12/4/2014 22:47 Ok so I'm pretty drunk and read through this and drrr surviving is suspicious as fuck with the healer roles being outed as stated. I'm not going to lynch because I'm not in the right state of mind to make a decision right now but I'll keep checking in! Tim you are an idiot just like Quentin how fitting (: Hey Vic there's this crazy thing where you should keep all conversation in this thread related to the actual game. I don't see how talking about Quentin is game related or how calling me an idiot is helping anything. You gonna actually contribute anything or is this post just to make sure you aren't seen as inactive while also agreeing with the majority opinion at the moment?

I contributed just like everyone else did and read my post about the recruiter also being the killer please

Wikey White @ 13/4/2014 9:30

Anyone who was quick to join DR's train is worth looking at. Curtis, Boc, Greenday, Vic, Vernon.

Still reading but wanted to point out that I didn't lynch DR

Okay so after reading ten pages of Tim BS.

I'm still up in the air on Panda's claim. It makes a lot of sense and I'm not even saying that he made up the role or anything, I just think the way he went about announcing it to us all seems a little off. I'm just thinking everything out and not in anyway accusing anyone of anything and I could be totally off, but idk.

Why did he come out and admit to having protected DR? What is the benefit in it for him? The only true benefit that I could see is if they are both scum, because otherwise, DR dying doesn't affect Panda. According to him, his role is now passive anyway so he can't perform anymore actions. Whether or not DR stays alive, Panda can't do anything more with his role.

Furthermore, it's not even like Panda knows DR's alignment. Why would he admit to using his role on her to help someone that could be mafia. If he's town, there isn't anyway that he could know DR's alignment, making it very odd that he would admit to using his role on her just to save her. The most logical reasoning for him to do it was if he knew they were on the same team, which would mean mafia.

Again, I'm not accusing them of being scum buddies, just trying to think out loud here. I think it makes a little bit of sense, but I also think he could be telling the truth. IDK.

drrr @ 13/4/2014 12:33

What? The only reason I am suspected and being lynched is because of my survival! A survival he can explain. Why would he let an innocent person die when the survival CAN be explained, and he gains nothing but becoming roleless from keeping silent? The benefit to announcing it is that it stops a mislynch that only started because of what he did. There's no downside to announcing it at all to save me.

I know. Which is why I sort of believe the claim. I'm just saying that he doesn't know what your alignment is, and for all he knows your scum that he just happened to use his role on.

Both sides of it make sense to me.

Hot Cocoa @ 13/4/2014 12:51

Herm @ 13/4/2014 12:46 Well, he said he was drunk so he might've not thought things through. I think we believe the claim because it feels awfully stupid to claim something like that if it's indeed false. The fact that Perry would claim, even though he's not sure whether Rose is scum or town, makes it suspicious though. So he could make anyone bulletproof without knowing their alignment? I didn't even think of it that way. I really hope he didn't make a mistake if he's telling the truth. If it was given to someone that was mafia or third party, it only makes them more powerful.

That's why I'm thinking it wouldn't make sense for him to announce it like that to save someone who's alignment he doesn't even know.

Could just ban Tim from the site (:

Honestly this Tim bullshit is making this game a lot less fun so Tim could you please stop trying to bring so much attention to yourself? I wanna play mafia not have a Tim petty party.

Hot Cocoa @ 13/4/2014 13:52

lol, I just got a FUCK YOU PM from somebody previously mentioned in my inbox.

Mine said Fucking Cunt

I'm not saying he's not scum but the REASONING for lynching Curtis being that he egged on Tim is silly IMO

Go ahead Vern lynch Nofo

Mafia doctor is why I said my theory about Panda and drrr being scum buddies. Panda could've said it to save her and because he might think he won't get tracked now. It's totally far fetched but I don't think it should be ruled out.

Vernon of 2014 @ 13/4/2014 16:11

Vic are you scum?

No

Caught red handed