Jack Frobst @ 9/12/2013 2:03

I'm also a little suspicious of Animal (basically only showed up to cast a lynch vote. Potentially just wanted to make sure that he didn't get any heat for being less active?) and im317 (was asking for votals, but didn't actually cast a vote. Could be he wanted to avoid trains to keep from garnering suspicion.) Out of those two, I'm most iffy on Animal, since he's got limited availability, but it seems odd that he'd push for a definitive lynch, then, for the same reasons it was weird that Vic cast a lynch vote before peacing out for the rest of the day. I don't really see either of those necessarily being more scummy than Jeff or Simplton, but it's worth keeping an eye on.

What do you mean by limited availability? lol I consistently checked the board to see if FF had checked back, even after I put my lynch vote in on him... well, until a certain point in the night anyway - then I actually forgot about mafia tbh but I made it a point to check back for awhile to see if he had checked in but he never did, so I left my lynch vote on him.

Also if by limited availability you mean finals week then ok. (: I have a final exam in like 4 hours and have been studying until now, and another exam Tues and another Weds - but after that, I'm done. Sorry if you think I'm lesser active or have "limited availability." While my priority is my education, I think I've been making it an effort to check in when necessary!

Anywho,

I actually don't find Simp that scummy, cuz he hasn't been afraid to voice his opinion which most scum would probably wanna lay back and let others take heat, but I think he's embracing the heat. Yeah he didn't really "come out guns blazing" until he was called out, but he still had differing opinions on D1, right? Like he wasn't afraid to say he disagreed with us about lynching FF. Now, if FF flipped mafia, then I could see Simp's opposition to the FF lynch as scummy, but otherwise I don't think it's scummy.

We really didn't get much info from D1, imo. Like people lynched others, but I don't think that's very scummy since FF was town anyway. The only thing I have questions for is why Vic can't lynch today but for some reason, I doubt we'll be getting an answer for that today.

I do agree w/ the FF lynch though because yeah he could have flipped to be the cop or doc but he wasn't being very useful even if he was, and he may not have protected or scanned anyone in the night, so if we're gonna lynch anyone, I agree with it having been him. Like, it sucks he was town but we had to do something, and simply no-lynching would have left us open in the night to a kill and having lynched no one would have left us with even less possible info. At least we tried!

Also lucky for us it seems the maf killed third party hehe

I guess I'd probably suspect that too. What I don't understand is why mafia wouldn't wanna get a train going on a more active member who already had votes on them (unless a mafia member already had votes on them... hmmm), but I guess that could also be fishy and make them stand out

Paco @ 9/12/2013 12:16

Angi Panda Animal Vic All 4 casted votes within like 20 minutes of each other. The Panda vote for some reason stuck out the most to me. It was ~10 minutes after Angi's but it seemed like Animal and Vic quickly followed. Like scum all coming on to dump votes on the train towards the end of the day.

Because if we were a mafia group, we'd want to all stand out by post one after the other? I don't understand that logic at all lol. Plus, why would mafia go out of their way to look suspicious if ff was more than likely going to be lynched anyway...?

Ari @ 9/12/2013 13:50

Therein lies the problem! I can even confirm my role, but ill wait to see what this is all about

Yeah I would wait! I doubt his role would be a face-off in a lynch vote between just the two of you. It'd practically be a death sentence for the person he challenged and would defeat the purpose of the vote, etc. We'll see

I would think mafia would want mismatching lynch votes so they can't be linked to one another

Or at least that's if we're dealing with a mafia that wants to remain hidden or w/e idk