1. Kim
2. B Rob
3. Jeremy
4. Cochran
5. Natalie A
Note, I haven't seen Earl's or Tom's season, so that might change things. JT is worth mentioning just because it's hard to deny the win when the jury vote is unanimous. Hatch is also great. Parvati would be on the list for me if she won HvV.
I included Natalie A on the list because I think that her game captured a lot of flexibility, rather than just squeaky clean control of the game. Like she bounced back quickly from her sister and Jeremy being voted out, was patient with her Jon move. She also did flashy things like "accidentally" voting for Alec, playing the idol on Jaclyn, giving up rewards, and offering to go to Exile. I actually thought she under-articulated her game in the FTC. Anywayyyyyyyy she may be a less objective add, but I really think being able to adapt is a strong quality of a winner. | That's a good point about Cochran. I didn't really consider the pre-game relationships. I think Chris and Danni both deserve a lot of credit for coming back from 6-1. I also really love Danni's win because she basically lied in confessionals because she knew the producers wanted Stephenie to win. Really really smart.
Also! There's a theory out there that if Micronesia is a final 3, Amanda actually wins in a plurality. Theory is this:
Amanda: Erik, James, Ozzy,
Parvati: Natalie, Jason
Cirie: Alexis, Eliza
However, I do think Cirie could have gotten Erik's vote.
Discussion of it here: https://www.reddit.com/r/survivor/comments/5u5cuk/who_wins_if_micronesia_is_a_final_3/ |