Would it be best to just mass-claim right away? Then everything is on the table.

It seems scummy for D1, but it's usually around this point in the game that it starts to get suggested anyway.

Thinking about it mathematically, it would be close. There will likely be 3 "extra" claims, and if we choose incorrectly on D1, then we're down to 8 (5-3). Vig kills correctly and so do maf and SK, leaving 3 town 2 non-town? I dunno, this is tough. Maybe we should hold off?

okay cool i'll start since no one else probably will

town hunter

i saw u sophia why'd you run away

I think it's important because we want as much info out as possible. We don't want something horrible, like vig visiting the PGO, to happen.

Matt @ 23/3/2015 12:47

Bomb can easily claim PGO, just as SK can easily claim BP.

Agreed, but then we will eventually know that one is lying.

I just don't know what else to do for today. Lynching incorrectly seems like a death sentence.

8 hours left and we still havent heard from angi or sami

I just don't know how else to figure out who to lynch. small fos on leos for suggesting a no lynch though

I also interpreted Matt's posts as very counterproductive. I get being cautious but, Matt, you weren't really offering other suggestions. Just saying we should keep everything hush hush.

Matt's just as good a lynch for me as anyone, I really don't know what to do.

I think the claim was best for us because then we can narrow it down to certain individuals. Now we're gonna have to get lucky at night iwth Vig/Sk/Maf kills going after the maf/sk

There are 3 of us on right now so we could do something, but I really don't know. About 10 mins left

i thinkkkkk the day ended 5 mins ago?

Successful night!

I feel like based on gut, the 2 members of the mafia consist of Angi/Lamps/Christian. I really have no basis for this but I guess we all gotta throw some names out there? I think the vig made a great choice in not killing. Right now we're ahead of the game and we don't need to blow it up by trying to guess who's mafia, and potentially losing 2 town with the vig and PGO.

Thoughts on this?

PGO claims. That way we know to absolutely not lynch them or visit them at night. Then mafia has to either let them get to the end or waste a kill on them, sacrificing one of their own. Plus with PGO claiming (we might get a counterclaim from the mafia bomb) we'll be that much closer to figuring this out? IDK I think it could set us up well with no third party. But obviously it's the PGO's choice.

Angi, I was throwing out names to try and generate discussion. I am willing to 100% believe that you are the town PGO unless we get a counterclaim, and even then, I'd probably believe you over the other person at this point. I just want to get people talking. I made it pretty clear my accusations were baseless, but I think everyone should be saying who they're suspicious of. We're in a good spot, but being quiet won't help us.