I saw this thread on Sucks. They went very elaborate with it, even going so far as to switch All Stars spots with the new placings. For example, the All Stars cast would be:

MOGO MOGO
Ryan Aiken (Winner, The Amazon)
Sonja Christopher (Winner, Borneo)
Kel Gleason (2nd Place, The Australian Outback)
Carl Bilancione (3rd Place, Africa)
Hunter Ellis (3rd, Marquesas)
Penny Ramsey (10th Place, Thailand)

SABOGA
Debb Eaton (Winner, The Australian Outback)
Stacey Stillman (3rd Place, Borneo)
Diane Ogden (Winner, Africa)
Alicia Caloway (8th Place, The Australian Outback)
Ryan Opray (8th Place, Pearl Islands)
Greg Buis (8th Place, Borneo)

CHAPERA
Daniel Lue (3rd Place, The Amazon)
Ramona Gray (4th Place, Borneo)
Jerri Manthey (9th Place, The Australian Outback)
Linda Spencer (4th Place, Africa)
Tammy Leitner (10th Place, Marquesas)
Michael Skupin (6th Place, The Australian Outback)

Following this logic, Debb Eaton is the only two time winner.

18. Michael Skupin
17. Tammy Leitner. Everyone cried.
16. Greg Buis (quit to be with his dying mother :'( )
15. Ryan Opray
14. Linda Spencer was BAMBOOZLED
13. Penny Ramsey (quit after being sexually violated by Linda)
12. Jerri Manthey
11. Hunter Ellis
10. Carl Bilancione
9. Alicia Caloway
8. Diane Ogden
7. Kel Gleason
6. Ramona Gray
5. Sonja Christopher
4. Daniel Lue (wins $1,000,000 as America's Favorite All Star)
3. Ryan Aiken
2. Stacey Stillman (proposes to Debb at the reunion)
1. Debb Eaton (wears a shirt saying "I Love Stacey", wins due to a presumed bitter jury, first and only two timer winner!!)

The next returnee season is Guatemala. Willard Smith and Ibrehem Rahman return.

The Favorites of Micronesia consist of the following:

Michelle Tesauro (3rd place, Pearl Islands)
Gary Stritesky (4th place, Fiji)
Cristina Coria (7th place, Cook Islands)
Bubba Sampson (6th place, Vanuatu)
Mia Galeotalanza (4th place, Vanuatu)
Billy Garcia (2nd place, Cook Islands)
Jaime Dugan (7th place, China)
Ruth-Marie Milliman (4th place, Panama)
Leslie Nease (3rd place, China)
Cao Boi Bui (6th place, Cook Islands)

I'm going to have to do the boot list for this once since it's actually important for hereos vs. villains!

20. Cao Boi Bui (asks to leave so that he can be with his expectant girlfriend)
19. Leslie Nease
18. Ruth-Marie Miliman
17. Natalie Bolton
16. Erik Reichenbach
15. Alexis Jones (TRAGICALLY EVACUATED. Returns for Philippines)
14. Jaime Dugan
13. Jason Siska (quits)
12. Billy Garcia
11. Mia Galeotalanza
10. Bubba Sampson (gets voted out after Kathy gave him a fake idol which was actually planted by Tracy)
9. Tracy Hughes-Wolf (Bubba is shocked. Fucks Mary in the bushes)
8. Kathy Sleckman
7. Chet Welsh
6. Jonathan Penner
5. Joel Anderson (voted out after giving up immunity to Mikey B )
4. Mikey Bortone
3. Gary Stritesky (screwed due to the final 2 twist)
2. Mary Sartain
1. Michelle Tesauro

^ tbh I would not mind watching a season with those favorites.

now it's time for HEROES VS. VILLAINS! Since this is the first time we've seen three-timers, I decided to use the latest season each player was in. For example, the person replacing Rupert would be the 4th place player in All Stars, aka Daniel Lue.

HEROES
Wanda Shirk (Winner, Palau)
Mary Sartain (2nd Place, Micronesia)
Gary Stritesky (3rd Place, Micronesia)
Morgan McDevitt (2nd Place, Guatemala)
Daniel Lue (4th Place, All Stars)
Jerri Manthey (12th Place, All Stars)
Paloma Soto-Castillo (3rd Place, Gabon)
Carolina Eastwood (Winner, Tocantins)
Flicka Smith (8th Place, Cook Islands)
Chet Welsh (7th place, Micronesia)

VILLAINS
Mike Borassi (2nd place, Samoa)
Michelle Tesauro (Winner, Micronesia)
Brendan Synott (8th place, Tocantins)
Spencer Duhm (5th place, Tocantins)
Melinda Hyder (2nd place, Panama)
Nicole Delma (Winner, Pearl Islands)
Hunter Ellis (11th, All Stars)
Stacey Stillman (2nd, All Stars)
Ashley Massaro (2nd, China)
Dan Kay (8th, Gabon)

20. Nicole Delma
19. Michelle Tesauro
18. Mike Borassi
17. Hunter Ellis
16. Jerri Manthey
15. Daniel Lue
14. Melinda Hyder
13. Flicka Smith
12. Mary Sartain
11. Carolina Eastwood
10. Ashley Massaro (falls victim to Morgan's infamous double idol scheme)
9. Spencer Duhm
8. Stacey Stillman
7. Chet Welsh
6. Brendan Synott
5. Wanda Shirk
4. Gary Stritesky
3. Dan Kay
2. Morgan McDevitt
1. Paloma Soto-Castillo

Redemption Island: Flicka Smith vs. Dan Kay

South Pacific: Mary Sartain vs. Tracy Hughes-Wolf

Alexis Jones, Amber Brkich, and Monica Padilla return for Philippines following their tragic medical evacs.

I made a mistake, it's actually Dan Kay

CARAMOAN FAVORITES

Marty Piombo (10th place, Nicaragua)
Joel Anderson (5th place, Micronesia)
Flicka Smith (20th place, Redemption Island)
Monica Padilla (4th place, Philippines)
Dan Kay (2nd place, Redemption Island)
Stephanie Valencia (5th place, Redemption Island)
Christine Shields Markosi (6th place, South Pacific)
Keith Tollefson (8th place, South Pacific)
Whitney Duncan (10th place, South Pacific)
Ace Gordon (7th place, Gabon)

20. Keith Tollefson (he eats a rock)
19. Whitney Duncan (these two are voted off back to back because everyone knows Whitney cheated on her husband with him)
18. Sherri Biethman
17. Eddie Fox (evacuated due to sand in his eye)
16. Joel Anderson
15. Marty Piombo (makes everyone's lives hell. Bikal votes him out at an immunity challenge)
14. Stephanie Valencia
13. Reynold Toepfer
12. Monica Padilla
11. Dan Kay
10. Michael Snow
9. Ace Gordon
8. Julia Landauer
7. Matt Bischoff
6. Christine Shields Markosi (I trusted you guys.)
5. Laura Alexander (passes out after BFF Christine is blindsided :'( )
4. Shamar Thomas (dog bar)
3. Hope Driskill (insults Laura at final tribal, losing all possible votes she could get.
2. Allie Pohevitz (Christine makes her take out her teeth)
1. Flicka Smith (landslide winner)

On her fourth attempt, Flicka Smith finally wins Survivor!

BLOOD VS. WATER. So much fact checking for this one ugh.

GALANG
Tina Scheer (Winner, Panama)
Brendan Synott (6th place, Heroes vs. Villains)
Stacey Stillman (8th place, Heroes vs. Villains)
Michael Skupin (18th place, All Stars)
Kelly Sharbaugh (10th place, Samoa)
Daniel Lue (15th place, Heroes vs. Villains)
Gretchen Cordy (7th place, Borneo)
Tarzan Smith (13th place, One World)
Alicia Rosa (14th place, One World)
Jonas Otsuji (7th place, One World)

TADHANA
Tina's Brother
Brendan's Wife
Stacey's Husband
Michael Skupin's son, Michael Skupin
Kelly's Daughter
Daniel's Girlfriend
Gretchen's Niece
Tarzan's Boyfriend
Alicia's Husband
Jonas' Girlfriend

20. Daniel Lue (swapped with his girlfriend on RI </3)
19. Alicia Rosa (quit after everybody on her tribe hated her)
18. Gretchen Cordy
17. Michael Skupin
16. Kelly's Daughter
15. Kelly Sharbaugh
14. Jonas' Girlfriend
13. Michael Skupin Jr.
12. Tarzan's Boyfriend
11. Tina's Brother
10. Tina Scheer
9. Brendan's Wife
8. Stacey's Husband
7. Jonas Otsuji
6. Alicia's Husband
5. Stacey Stillman
4. Gretchen's Niece
3. Daniel's Girlfriend
2. Tarzan Smith
1. Brendan Synnott