Rodney @ 20/2/2021 22:54

They Cody and TT thing just seems so convenient and it's the only thing I have to go from today. I just have a hard time with Cody blocking him

Well, you cc'ing Badger yesterday was very convenient too.

Yes, I was blocked last night.

Hi Herm

If we want to be sure about recruiting, I think we should lynch 317 or Maddie today.

On a side note, Spin had added as subtitle for D4 "I love the smell of explosives in the morning", then the arsonist was lynched. So perfectly fitting.

Herm @ 21/2/2021 0:00

My personal preference would be im317 over Maddie. I'm not sure we're dealing with recruitment tbh, but who knows lol.

Yeah, I'm not sure if that confirmation should be our focus today. But if it is, then those are the lynches.

Herm @ 21/2/2021 2:51

I do want to see TT and im317 chip in a little more tbh, it just makes me think they're scum the way they're playing. I'll give Maddie a break.

I was asleep at that time, baby.
I'm not Lamps level of timezone difference but still have some hours ahead of USA.

BTW, why not give me a break too? :(

BTW, the way Maddie barely commits to lynches still looks more scummy to me.

Also: if Spin can give Rodney that alleged role without any recruitment happening, I wouldn't be surprised if we have only Curtis (maybe Timmah because of wording) as vanilla with farlig role.

Herm @ 21/2/2021 11:39

Tattered Tooth @ 21/2/2021 16:13 Herm @ 21/2/2021 2:51 I do want to see TT and im317 chip in a little more tbh, it just makes me think they're scum the way they're playing. I'll give Maddie a break. I was asleep at that time, baby. I'm not Lamps level of timezone difference but still have some hours ahead of USA. BTW, why not give me a break too? :( Oh, I am also a different timezone. Same as Lamps I believe. Alright, I'll give you a break too. :) Hope my suspicion of you isn't too annoying? You were blocked last night tho. Who do you think is scum.and why? Respond when you can.

Oh, I was sure you were from NA.
So you don't sleep like ever? o_O

Anyway, I think we have possible 3 scenarios, with the most likely on the top:

► Only 2 non-recruiting Pakistani: that would be Maddie and one of 317/Rodney;

► Pakistani, but they actually could recruit: this branches out to 2 other scenarios, but I'm sticking with the most likely for now - Rodney told us the truth, which means 317 is the most likely to be recruited on N2 (IF they only can recruit vanilla AND failed to recruit N1) and Maddie was with Ahoda from start;

► Non-recruiting Pakistani + another faction (starting leader and their recruits): All of Maddie, 317 and Rodney are scum, with Rod as cult leader.

Herm @ 21/2/2021 11:56

Tattered Tooth @ 21/2/2021 16:19 BTW, the way Maddie barely commits to lynches still looks more scummy to me. Also: if Spin can give Rodney that alleged role without any recruitment happening, I wouldn't be surprised if we have only Curtis (maybe Timmah because of wording) as vanilla with farlig role. If Rodney is scum, it's a fake claim. Badger could be recruited so we know it's a thing.

Hmmm, when I first read the "(if possible)" in his role description, I took it as "if there is any recruitment in the game".

I understand why Cody chose to block me.

And I'm sorry guys if I am not analyzing the multiple possible scenarios so much, my way of scumhunting is a bit more on a person to person steps.

im317 @ 21/2/2021 16:58

i think i have further narrowed down my options to just Herm or Maddie. someone sell me on either or them

Although I had my doubts on Herm for the first days (even being so active), being a commuter makes sense since it helps to explain the no kills on N1. So unless a very unlikely commuting cult leader is in this game, now I trust him more than ever.

Maddie did have solid reasons for not being so active on D4, but that's not the problem.
As I stated some times already, when she suddenly didn't want to lynch on D2 (choosing to "follow Timmah" voting for non-present Lamps instead) made me sus of her.
After that, D3 was basically speculation. She did interact a bit with Reaper, yet no votes again. Her most notable suspicions have been a OMGUS on me.

Has been for a while, heh.

I'm not sure yet... But I stated on my other post that it could be 317 or Rod.

Gabagool @ 21/2/2021 18:16

You do not want to lynch me if you are Kashmiri.

Based on?

Gabagool @ 21/2/2021 18:19

That was not me "not wanting to lynch" on D2. I was at a digital work event and didn't come back in time to vote.

You are mixing up the days, I guess you meant D3.

D2 you posted until the very end, switching from Penner to Lamps.

Cody @ 21/2/2021 18:52

I’m actually wondering the same. I don’t think it’s likely that 317 and Maddie are a pair right.

Why not?

I'm fine lynching whoever Herm and Cody decide from those 3, since someone must be Maddie's scumpartner after all.

If we weight in cult, 317 would be the most assured way to check IF they only can recruit vanilla.