Lamps @ 12/8/2019 12:32

##lynch im317 I see you

just got here like 5 minutes ago. want to go play Fire Emblem more so i skimmed a bit. are we not waiting on the results of a day kill? anyways as i have said before i am still town. that said i am vanilla town so if for some reason you need to lynch me to help town win at least it wont be that big a loss. i will read up on this day later but im going to take advantage of some unexpected time right now where i can play games.

i am town. i have not been as active this game and this day in particularly because i have spent the majority of my free time playing the new Fire Emblem game. i have read part of this day now and i have to say i dont like the way Mittens is tunneling on Timmah

Mittens @ 11/8/2019 22:37

My top of the list is TIB and timmah

TiB would have been a terrible choice. if we think he is scum we should at least test his claim so he can take another suspect out with him if hes telling the truth.

50 posts in and my top scum reads are Mittens and Herm

Lamps @ 12/8/2019 3:55

IM317 said this yesterday: "just want to point out that the hider did not die by hiding behind scum. now on to post 351" There was not even a "you die if you hide behind scum" condition in Rodney's role. Is that why you said that IM?

yeah i was pointing that part out so we didn't start to go down the wrong road by thinking that could have been a factor.

100 posts in and Nav looks worse then before. TiB/Wikey/Cody look like lead pipe locks for town.

Prince Navneeta @ 12/8/2019 6:35

I'm Town x-shot bus driver. On N1 I swapped Rodney and Cultis. For the lols more than any reads I had and it ended up saving Rodney (so you're welcome Rod!) N2 my action failed because of the Nexus. Can't bus drive Lamps with himself. N3 I swapped Penner and Herm. Which is why I didn't buy any "Penner was redirected" theories that Calvin was spouting N4: I swapped myself with Cody. I had kept it vague yesterday about what I would do. If you look closely I alluded to saving myself on N3 and also egging Mafia on to come after me. Unfortunately it didn't work so Shrug I've tried to use the role protectively, swapping a town read of mine with a scum read. There you go Wiley.

i question the x shot and town part of this claim. attempting to bus a kill away from scum mate Curtis night 1. you could say whatever about night 2 thanks to the nexus. swapping scum Herm with Penner to try and protect him night 3 and busing yourself and Cody night 4 to prevent anyone from verifying his claim.

wikeyb9m3bek @ 12/8/2019 6:42

Seeing it all spelt out again reassures me about Nav once more. He knew Cavin was a killer because he bussed his Rodney kill to Curtis. Could Nav be scum Bus Driver? Yeah, but only if he is a bad one. If so, he got his scum buddy Curtis killed N1, and exposed the SK yesterday (scum would still have wanted Cavin around I imagine)

got town cred for exposing the SKer and could have been trying to protect Curtis.

150 posts in plus a Mittens role claim and my scum list reads.

Herm and Nav, in that order.

250 posts in and Herm is by far my top scum read. Nav is still up there but i think we learn something about Nav if Herm flips scum.

oh and i am not listing Josh as a scum read because read implies that its not a 100% locked in fact, and there is no way non scum Josh claims 3rd party killer.

Prince Navneeta @ 12/8/2019 12:10

Herm @ 12/8/2019 8:07 Penner @ 12/8/2019 17:51 Why wasn’t I motivated last night :( I used it on Farlig two nights in a row in an attempt to ensure that scum's target would be protected. But in retrospect, it probably would've been better to use it on you lol. So garlic had 2 uses of his doc save last night and is still dead?

Herm @ 12/8/2019 12:10

Yes.

Prince Navneeta @ 12/8/2019 12:11

That's less believable than Cody's cockamamie claim

wikeyb9m3bek @ 12/8/2019 12:35

Herm @ 12/8/2019 11:33 Maybe im317 is scum and Curtis only put a lynch vote on him because they were bussing each other? I do wonder if one of the three players Curtis named were scum now. Just to muddy the waters later on. It's also possible he meant absolutely nothing by it at all though

Curtis did not just say he thought i was scummy. he put a vote on me that added me to the tie at 2 votes each, making me 1 of 4 with two votes. this was also fairly close to the deadline when he did that.

350 posts in and im slightly less sold on scum Herm, but he is still my top scum read.

400 posts in and this is more based on the last 50 i read but Mittens is only scum if Herm is also scum.

also Nav feels more scum now and Herm a little bit less yet again. think Nav is close to passing Herm.

tried to post this but the thread was locked. on the bright side i saw Josh's flip and Mittens is not 100% cleared. i also feel much better about Herm now because scum Herm would have motivated Josh.

i know im not caught up yet but through 400 posts i feel confident enough to cast a vote to

##lynch Nag

450 posts and thanks to Cody i have a plan

Nav today
TiB tomorrow if the game is not over, and have TiB shoot Timmah
Cody the day after that if the game is still not over

Cody @ 12/8/2019 16:31

So Timmah nor Nav killed last night Unless Mittens is lying

well now we know Josh must have done the kill. could not have been Nav since Penner got the results of a busing.

Cody @ 12/8/2019 17:58

317 why don’t you think this clears Mittens?

typo, was distracted. was supposed to say now instead of not.