yeah i read it as he was part of the Final Girls Mafia, just a missing member like we often see. thought with so many players there could be a second mafia, but i think the theme fits better for a SKer or Cult. in fact with 41 it could be both.

Mads @ 17/10/2018 22:26

I would have expected more deaths in a game that's 41 people and horror themed. Interested... And one of them was the hider AND town RB is dead.

Christian @ 17/10/2018 23:13

unless Lamps decided it'd be too risky on Night 1, he likely died hiding behind scum or someone who got killed.

these things are why i think there is probably some less common 3rd party role in play. it looks like there were only 2 deaths plus hider hiding behind scum(or hiding behind someone who was killed), so either we have no vig or they no killed? i mean between the number of players and the theme we kind of have to have a SKer. thought i guess it could be some arson variant. dont think arson specifically as i dont see any horror films that fit, but mass poison or terrorist maybe?

Ari @ 18/10/2018 2:40

Correct me if I'm wrong but these are the people who didn't vote yesterday.. Why did you guys not vote anyone? Brian Havo im317 JJ Jamie KC Merc Mike Patrick Porl Roland Shawn Timmah Vic Zach Did this on my phone so hope I didn't miss anyone

i knew i wouldn't be around for the end of the day. so i chose to not vote rather then cast a vote 4+ hours before deadline that i could not remove.

as for who i would lynch, maybe Merc. Lamps did vote for him, so maybe that was his breadcrumb. and its not like we can lynch Zersch. thought people seem to be missing that Lamps could have also hid behind DS and died from DS being killed.

Helios Garabandia @ 18/10/2018 11:35

Why in the hell would Primate claim there?

i was going to have a theory about tracking the same person every night, like a non bastard version of Billy from ATTWS IV, i think we have seen it once since then, but...

Darkus Black @ 18/10/2018 12:05

Folks. Primate has some outside stuff to deal with. Go and see the depressing news thread for more details. He probably claimed to avoid getting lynched as town if he is not around to defend himself.

clearly there was another reason and it really sucks. sorry Primate, was hoping she would recover from that fall.

farlig @ 18/10/2018 12:39

Hiding behind DS N1 makes no sense with his reputation and general dislike by most here.

i agree its highly unlikely, but given that why Lamps died is important and may lead us to a member of the mafia i think its useful to keep track of all our options. i mean someone else said he could have not hid and been a normal kill target, yet nobody had said he could have hid behind DS.

Helios Garabandia @ 18/10/2018 13:29

im317 @ 18/10/2018 12:16 farlig @ 18/10/2018 12:39 Hiding behind DS N1 makes no sense with his reputation and general dislike by most here. i agree its highly unlikely, but given that why Lamps died is important and may lead us to a member of the mafia i think its useful to keep track of all our options. i mean someone else said he could have not hid and been a normal kill target, yet nobody had said he could have hid behind DS. Do we really think a hider wouldn't have hidden N1?

no. my point was that despite that being highly unlikely we have this post

Christian @ 17/10/2018 23:13

unless Lamps decided it'd be too risky on Night 1, he likely died hiding behind scum or someone who got killed.

so i thought i should bring up the more probable option of him hiding behind DS. it seems like some people missed that he died if the person he hid behind was killed.

Mittens @ 18/10/2018 15:52

##Lynch im317 I'm still not understanding what he's getting at with the Lamps stuff, and it just feels weird to be harping on a non-issue.

i was trying to lay out all the ways Lamps could have died. im 99% sure i was the first person to point out that Lamps could have died from hiding behind DS specifically. it seemed like everyone was assuming he either hid behind Zersch or a mafia member and were overlooking the fact that he could have hid behind DS and died because DS was killed.

not sure what is confusing about that. im dont even think its the most probably of the ways he could have died, but i felt it needed to be kept in mind.

the real issue is to figure out if Lamps vote on Merc was 100% FElistrations based or if he was also hinting at who he was going to hide behind. of course the only way to know for sure is to lynch Merc, but at this point i think we are better off just keeping an eye on Merc and lynching someone who has done something suspicious instead.

of the 3 leading lynch trains the only one i think has done anything suspicious is Darkus with his jumping his vote around like crazy in the last hour of day 1. which is suspicious because all the people who had even 1 vote were close to the lead, so his moving his vote often pushed the person he moved to either into the lead or 1 vote back, and with it moving so often it must have been difficult to keep track of. the problem with that is its a very WIFOM situation in that would scum Darkus do that.

still we need to start focusing on someone, so lets turn up the pressure and

##lynch Darkus

Mittens @ 18/10/2018 17:18

im317 @ 18/10/2018 15:58 Mittens @ 18/10/2018 15:52 ##Lynch im317 I'm still not understanding what he's getting at with the Lamps stuff, and it just feels weird to be harping on a non-issue. i was trying to lay out all the ways Lamps could have died. im 99% sure i was the first person to point out that Lamps could have died from hiding behind DS specifically. it seemed like everyone was assuming he either hid behind Zersch or a mafia member and were overlooking the fact that he could have hid behind DS and died because DS was killed. not sure what is confusing about that. im dont even think its the most probably of the ways he could have died, but i felt it needed to be kept in mind. the real issue is to figure out if Lamps vote on Merc was 100% FElistrations based or if he was also hinting at who he was going to hide behind. of course the only way to know for sure is to lynch Merc, but at this point i think we are better off just keeping an eye on Merc and lynching someone who has done something suspicious instead. 3 people died last night. Lamps DS Zersch So when Christian said he could've died hiding behind someone who got killed.. of course that meant hiding behind DS. I'm confused why you are pushing the fact that you've come up with a novel idea that Lamps could've died by hiding behind DS.. it's 1 of 2 (or 3 if you really want to think he didn't submit an action) possibilities.

we really should move on from this but i just have to point out that you are missing a major posability right now.

1. hide behind Zersch
2. hide behind DS
3. do not hide and be targeted for a kil
4. hide behind scum other then Zersch

the fact that this far into things you forget the option that has the highest number of ways it could occur is proof that i needed to bring up the way Lamps could have died that nobody else had specifically said.

anyways this has all be a distraction so how about we drop it and move on?

so i dont really get the Herm votes, nothing really stands out.