i suppose the questions to ask are

Buffy did anything bad happen to you?
Vic do you know why you survived?
Ahoda, Spin, Free Candy, Vlady, Drr, Timmah why did you vote Farlig over Free Candy?

Vic @ 8/11/2017 21:09

Yes I do know why I survived

thanks. still need to hear from Buffy, also interested to see if FC has anything to say.

lets see what new leads today brings.

Timmah @ 8/11/2017 22:10

Spin @ 8/11/2017 21:02 I voted Farlig because he was the lowest poster after rose showed up. When he came back, and it was down to him and Free Candy, I stayed with Farlig, because it didn't seem like he cared, which I took as being scum-leaning. Turns out I was wrong, and we lynched the wrong person. ## Lynch Free Candy This is exactly what I recall. Why are people trying to paint it that there was some late switch to farlig in order to save Free Candy. What I recall is farlig got votes because he was low poster, and at all times near the end of the Day was leading in lynch votes over free candy. I recall Robb trying to save farlig and lynch free candy, and honestly I voted farlig more because of that than anything. Today, I find it highly suspicious that some people are trying to paint things in a false light to fit how they want to push things.

i agree that Farlig looked like crap day 1, HoL level crap imo. still its one of the things that happened day 1 so i figured it was worth asking. the way people are reacting to the question is in itself telling. im not sure what it tells, but i think it tells something.

Timmah @ 8/11/2017 23:22

Spin @ 8/11/2017 22:18 Timing of D1 Votes (on Farlig and FC) -- All times CT Votes for Farlig in purple. Votes for Free Candy in orange Ahoda -- 5:00 pm (11/6) ==> Farlig up 1-0 Savage -- 5:43 am ==> Tied vote (1-1) Curtis -- 3:44 pm ==> Farlig up 2-1 JJ -- 3:46 pm ==> Tied vote (2-2) Spin -- 4:01 pm ==> Farlig up 3-2 DS -- 4:10 pm ==> Tied vote (3-3) Free Candy -- 4:14 pm ==> Farlig up (4-3) Vlady -- 4:14 pm ==> Farlig up (5-3) drrr -- 4:16 pm ==> Farlig up (6-3) drrr unvote -- 4:17 pm ==> Farlig up (5-3) ??? -- sometime between 4:16 and 4:21 pm ==> Farlig up (5-4) drrr -- 5:19 pm ==> Farlig up (6-4) Chris -- 5:40 pm ==> Farlig up (6-5) Timmah -- 6:54 pm ==> Farlig up (7-5) Navneet -- 6:55 pm ==> Farlig up (7-6) Day ends 5 minutes later. See, this notion of a late flip to farlig is a myth. I’d also forgotten the ??? Vote on FC. Read that as a scum vote thief role, but if FC flips mafia maybe not.

would a vote thief have stolen a vote yet for day 1? seems more like an anonymous vote role, which could also be scum.

Timmah @ 9/11/2017 14:30

Honestly, I don't think I can see spin making that move if he was just bluffing or making it up as scum to get FC killed/lynched. Especially since it was FC, who was going to be more detrimental to the town than helpful even without his role.

i agree, it would take a Buffy sized cup of wine to make any sense for him to lie.

Mittens @ 9/11/2017 16:15

Regina Ferno @ 9/11/2017 14:05 Mittens why is spin not mafia role cop? I personally wouldn't put myself out there to get someone lynched who isn't a threat anymore. FC had already used his poisoning, so it doesn't make much sense to me that Spin would pull that move and put himself in the crosshairs.

would role cop know its a 1 shot? not that i think hes role cop.

Herm @ 9/11/2017 17:08

I don't understand the Patrick vote either, which makes me wonder about Vic.

Herm @ 9/11/2017 17:10

JohnnyDollar @ 9/11/2017 23:02 I feel like our votes are all over the place. Why are people jumping on these seemingly random votes? Maybe I've missed something. No one has cc'd bulletproof, which seems to be in Vic's favor. I'm half-thinking he could still be scum though.

wow, a 180 in 2 minutes with no posts in between?

took me forever to get caught up. looks like Maddie or Patrick? i don't love either of those votes, but i love the Patrick vote less since he seems to be more active.