im tired so if this post makes no sense please forgive me.

this lynch is based on faulty logic imo. why would someone who survives a kill attempt due to BP claim to have no idea why they survived when multiple protective roles are already dead? i would think claiming town BP would have a better chance in the short term for the don. sure they still die soon but they force the real town BP to counter claim. i suppose a 3rd party BP would need to find a different explanation due to there win conditions.

i have an idea but i need to be more awake to think it thought.

ah fuck it.

if drr flips and is not BP then i think Curtis is mafia.

Panda you protect drr each night? also i take back Curtis being mafia if drr flips as not BP since we have new info. im still suspicious of Curtis thought, just not as much.

Panda The Buffy Slayer @ 13/4/2014 15:00

I will answer all the questions and theories I have read. I have no clue what alignment Rose is I just thought it was stupid to let her get lynched when I knew what was up. But yeah she is now bulletproof through the game. I also did not see the big deal cause my role was already used up. So I don't picture mafia killing me off now or bothering with Rose. So I am hoping she is town and we just trimmed down 2 people and made this easier.

Buffy @ 13/4/2014 15:34

Wiki says Seraph Knight could be a town or mafia role but that Mafia-aligned Seraph Knight is much more reasonable.

does this role make them BP until the Knight dies or does the Knight protect them until they die?

##lynch Curtis

if its any consolation its not because of the Tim thing, its because i think you are mafia

Greendayger @ 13/4/2014 17:38

Boc @ 13/4/2014 17:11 Greenday wut. How can your role be beneficial to the town and not harmful to the mafia. A beneficial town role IS by definition harmful to the mafia! (: Probably not necessary for you to be softclaiming just yet anyway tho My role only works on cult

hold up. as in there is a cult and you can un-recruit there members?

Angi @ 13/4/2014 19:09

20 pages again, lovely lol What is WITH all the animal avatars btw lmfao

i did it before it was cool

Curtis @ 13/4/2014 19:15

So uhh...should I claim? (: . Not much time is left and I'm currently gonna die because of a very bad train im317, I know what your theory is and it's incorrect

you really think you know what my theory is? do you know why i think it too? anyways its not the strongest theory and i gave no explanation for it. all that combines to make Herm's vote(and especaly the way he talked in the post he made it in) seem way out of place to me.

##unlynch
##lynch Herm

Curtis @ 13/4/2014 19:34

im317 @ 13/4/2014 19:32 Curtis @ 13/4/2014 19:15 So uhh...should I claim? (: . Not much time is left and I'm currently gonna die because of a very bad train im317, I know what your theory is and it's incorrect you really think you know what my theory is? do you know why i think it too? anyways its not the strongest theory and i gave no explanation for it. all that combines to make Herm's vote(and especaly the way he talked in the post he made it in) seem way out of place to me. ##unlynch ##lynch Herm I sure do!

if you know that then you really cant blame me for thinking it points to you being mafia. in fact of the top of my head i cant think of a way to interpret it with you having a town role. grated if i did a little thinking im sure i could think of a role or 3.

drrr @ 13/4/2014 19:39

Now lets see who the first to claim this train was too fast to start and take off

i would but Mal doesn't seem to care enough.

Quote

This is very confusing. If you have a theory as to why he could be mafia, you should share.

its not that strong a theory and stuff has happened that makes me think it less likely. so i dont think its worth sharing.

##unlynch

i dont like the Mal train but i dont like how Mal is not defending himself either, makes me worry about a bomb so im not going to join it.