Nofo @ 4/1/2014 20:10

:( This is getting really shitty. So now we can deduce that the nun chose the wrong person and the serial killer killed the person the bodyguard chose? Is that right? Three killers doesn't make sense with today's results, right?

why couldn't the bodyguard have been the target?

Nofo @ 4/1/2014 20:14

im317 @ 4/1/2014 21:12 Nofo @ 4/1/2014 20:10 :( This is getting really shitty. So now we can deduce that the nun chose the wrong person and the serial killer killed the person the bodyguard chose? Is that right? Three killers doesn't make sense with today's results, right? why couldn't the bodyguard have been the target? They could have been, I was just thinking that it could be possible that it was an accident.

oh yeah its possible. the more active players are dropping like flies, a cheap but effective tactic.

Drr why do you have a gun?

"ITEMS

1) Since this is Christmas, you may receive a gift in the mail!
2) There will be guns in this game. Each gun has a different degree of accuracy and has different odds of killing a target.
3) Some items are crucial for specific roles to be effective. If you come across an item that seems pointless, it might be in your best interest to pass it on!
4) The post office is only available at night. You may choose any of your items to gift to someone else, but you are not permitted to exchange items during the day."

Kiwi @ 4/1/2014 23:41

Is only 1 of the 5 scum?

the role said at least one

im317 @ 4/1/2014 20:39

Drr why do you have a gun?

Quote

I have no idea! I got them both last night in the mail. The gun has a 50/50 chance of working and can only be fired in the daytime. The vest protects from a nightkill or another gun.

fair enough.

deaderrose @ 4/1/2014 23:54

Kiwi @ 4/1/2014 23:50 Hmmmm And what you think of Colby's note? It's interesting and probably worth going for one of the three, but I wanna hear from them all before we start lynching blindly.

im an oppressed civilian, i am also the one who sent you that vest. i can prove my claim if i have to.

Kiwi @ 5/1/2014 0:05

the vest and not the gun?

correct. hence why i only asked about the gun.

Vic @ 5/1/2014 0:07

im317 @ 5/1/2014 0:06 Kiwi @ 5/1/2014 0:05 the vest and not the gun? correct. hence why i only asked about the gun. So you can vouch that I'm telling the truth about my role then

i can vouch that she does indeed have a vest as i gave it to her.

Kiwi @ 5/1/2014 0:09

Perhaps Rose was sent out by the mafia? Idk about two different people giving her two different items.

the different items doesn't bother me, after all i happen to have given a as yet unnamed person an as yet unnamed item out on night 1(which is how i can prove my claim btw). getting 2 items in 1 night is unusual thought.

Kiwi @ 5/1/2014 0:16

Ahh. I don't understand how this item concept. Is it explained somewhere? Like does the Godfather have to give a gun to someone in this version of mafia?

http://www.ndimforums.com/fe/thread.asp?threadid=1998&pp=50#new

the items appear to be single use, so i figure there separate from ability's from a players role. plus it would be not so in the spirit of the role for don and/or SKer to scan as holding a weapon that is part of there role.

Kiwi @ 5/1/2014 0:23

Hmm I see. Well I think we should turn to Wikey and nofo.

i concur. sadly i need to get some sleep now so i have to withdraw from this thread until the morning

Tom Brady @ 5/1/2014 10:07

So, as I was reading through, I thought Kiwi was pretty insistent that Greenday should not be considered as a lynch candidate yesterday, and I thought it odd. Based just on day 2, I could see Kiwi and Greenday been scum buddies. This is all just speculation. If you notice, in that same post I name DR and im317 as suspects too. This is by no means me making solid accusations. It is all speculation, me throwing all my thoughts out as they come to me. I am actually more interested in the DR, im317, Nofo thing.

again i gave someone else an item night 1. i would rather not say who it was or what the item is but i suppose its ok to say that i have the Rosary Buffy's role needed to get 2x power.

Tom Brady @ 5/1/2014 10:16

I am trying to get my head round it. DR hasn't claims that she was passed the gun and armour last night. im317 has confirmed that he gave her the armour. I would like to know his reasons for doing so, because DR has hardly been giving off obv town vibes. And she also claims she was passed the gun. This could be a lie. Nobody has come forward about passing it to her, which is interesting because I don't think a townie would have anything to lose by doing so. It would clear this up for us. So, either DR is telling the truth and a townie has yet to come forward, she had the gun from the start and is SK/GF, or she is scum and one of her scum buddies passed it to her, and now dare not come forward for fear of exposing themselves. I would like to know what Vic meant earlier too, when he said that the role came up as Oppressed Civilian. Is he talking about DR, or himself? Because he claimed he just found out what items his target had, not their alignment too.

i gave Drr the armor because she was actually trying at being helpful, something we were in very short supply of at that point.

Greenday @ 5/1/2014 12:19

ff_zero @ 5/1/2014 11:26 It always irks me and seems scummy to me when people say if you lynch me its all over, town is going to lose, very very bad, etc. Just does. Doesn't mean it is always true. 'cept in this case it does. Lynch me today, power goes out, we lose someone else, mafia bands together in the dark to all vote anonymously; game over.

sometimes town can be so stupid. mafia cant win if there is 3rd party still alive. if mafia has majority and there is 3rd party alive the game continues, its possible for town to get majority back and still win in the case.

##lynch Wikey
6/15 now. we can go into the lynch at either 6/14 or 5/14 if Drr day kills Nofo. i would rather go in with 14 and know we are lynching scum, or have time to change targets because we day killed scum