Paco - N/A - scanned town
Patrick - visits random player, does nothing to them
Vic - N/A

im fairly sure one of you three is our killer but i dont know which one

Paco @ 28/12/2013 20:28

Mass role claim time? Who has claimed so far or been exposed as whatever role?

Animal - commuter- confirmed by Colby to have been not at home one night
im317 - N/A - scanned town
Paco - N/A - scanned town
Patrick - visits random player, does nothing to them
Rob - resurrected
Panda - challenger - confirmed by challenge
Vic - N/A

that is all the info we have as far as i remember.

Paco @ 28/12/2013 20:36

I was wondering something by the way....what would Nofo's role be considered? SK or just another 3rd Party? Since the role says one of them (Matt wound up being the other) must kill I'm thinking that is a pseudo SK role and the 1 scum remaining is mafia.

how convenient for you that the remaining player is in your theory mafia, since the cop cleared you of that.

Jack Frobst @ 28/12/2013 22:29

Well, let's not forget that usurpers usually scan as vanilla after taking over for the Don. It's a pretty standard role for a game this size, and I don't recall one showing up among the ones we've killed.

i never even considered that

http://www.ndimforums.com/fe/thread.asp?threadid=1971&postsby=87#68522

"I think this is right, but I could be wrong:

Night 1: DD (went to Matt)
Night 2: Panda (Town)
Night 3: Curtis
Night 4: Greenday (when Colby visited me)
Night 5: Earthbound
Night 6: im317
Night 7: Shawn
Night 8: Paco
Night 9: Jeff"

i need to get some sleep, i will think on this

Vic @ 29/12/2013 10:50

I still think Panda is the biggest scum suspect. I have no problem claiming at all but I don't have a way to prove my role

how does that even work? he scanned as town according to the cop and we have seen his role in action. he has no way to kill unless hes mafia and he scanned as town. he is the single most confirmed town in the game from an outside perspective(since we each know we ourselves are town but not everyone does)

unless someone wants to claim vig Rob is also more or less confirmed.

Animal @ 29/12/2013 12:16

I barely trust the scan when half the roles scan as town anyway. Sometimes there's 1 town member that scans as mafia and 1 mafia member that scans as town too I don't think perry is confirmed town. Vic it wouldn't hurt to role claim so we know what we are dealing with. Everyone should just role claim tbh. FOS @ you if you don't

one should only role claim if it helps the town, or as a last resort when they have become the lynch target. my claiming would not help the town and as such im not going to

Animal @ 29/12/2013 12:49

Lol I just read Justin's role exactly, who was his informant? O.o

Matt who committed suicide night 1 after his mentor Nofo was killed.

Vic @ 29/12/2013 13:41

Paco @ 29/12/2013 12:49 Vic I would like yo hear your claim since you're pretty much the only person we gave virtually no information about. Everyone else still alive has either claimed or been scanned as town by Justin. I am the Princess. If I am killed at night than it will skip the next day phase

pick one

5 or 6

Paco @ 29/12/2013 14:27

im317 @ 29/12/2013 14:26 Vic @ 29/12/2013 13:41 Paco @ 29/12/2013 12:49 Vic I would like yo hear your claim since you're pretty much the only person we gave virtually no information about. Everyone else still alive has either claimed or been scanned as town by Justin. I am the Princess. If I am killed at night than it will skip the next day phase pick one 5 or 6 ???

dont worry im not asking you

Patrick do you have anything helpful to say? still waiting for Panda to show up.

Vic @ 29/12/2013 16:22

im317 @ 29/12/2013 14:26 Vic @ 29/12/2013 13:41 Paco @ 29/12/2013 12:49 Vic I would like yo hear your claim since you're pretty much the only person we gave virtually no information about. Everyone else still alive has either claimed or been scanned as town by Justin. I am the Princess. If I am killed at night than it will skip the next day phase pick one 5 or 6 Uh...5? I will probably be killed tonight now so that the next day skips and benefits whoever we are looking for. AKA why I did not want to reveal.

meh. if you are lynched does anything happen? it might be better to lynch you and have 1 night phase instead of having you get killed and there being 2 night phases.

i dont have a better idea so sure

##lynch Rob