wait Cult had someone take over as recruiter when the leader died? that might kind of be a good thing. between that and Penner explaining why there were 3 kills night 1 it means there is probably not a SKer. also a more powerful cult might mean a smaller mafia team. thought i figure they still have at least 4

Penner @ 20/10/2023 22:07

I’m not ready to say we have a Town Vig (Cody). We have a lot of protection roles on town already (doc, nurse, bodyguard, TiB’s beguiler, my PGO, and Brian/I being able to vouch as masons). And per usual, the clear correct option for a Vig to kill (Sami) remains alive

true he could be SKer. that said i think he has to be off the table today since we really need to hit mafia.

Sami @ 20/10/2023 22:54

im317 you're cool, why you no like Stargate's post

secret. leave it be for now

does anyone have a reason Rose is not scum? because i feel like we all seem to agree she is.

so im not sure i trust Penner is the Hoda thing. also i have been trying the puzzle because i like puzzles. that said i would be the worst pick for Hoda because im 100% being killed tonight.

Cody @ 20/10/2023 23:31

Kat, 317. Do you believe Steph is that why you want to vote rose?

not ruling it out is more of it. if nothing else i want to hear from Rose. Curtis too for that matter. were to close to losing to let them not talk

Penner @ 20/10/2023 23:45

im317 @ 20/10/2023 23:32 so im not sure i trust Penner is the Hoda thing. also i have been trying the puzzle because i like puzzles. that said i would be the worst pick for Hoda because im 100% being killed tonight. Seriously? The only risk is if you think a double backup recruiter exists and wants to pick me

its just that i dont totally trust you to think it all the way thought. and i 100% should not be it. town has lost doctor, nurse, bodyguard, watcher and tracker. there is almost no chance we have protective roles left, so im for sure going to be killed next.

Stargate @ 21/10/2023 0:00

I trust Penner is town more than I do 317. His asking to be lynched felt more like scum knowing if they did that they wouldn't be and wouldn't be looked at by a vig either since they're saying when they die it's good for Mafia. But then why hasn't Mafia killed you?

because my reads suck this game and there saving me for later since we have not killed any of them. i was clear as far back as day 2 that the longer the game went on the bigger a threat my death is to town

Penner @ 21/10/2023 0:12

I will think through the situation with Steph tomorrow on a clearer brain, but at this point I think it needs to be Cody or Steph

why would Cody do literally anything he has all game as mafia? this is the kind of post that has me worried about what you will do as Heda

interesting claim. still need to hear from Curtis