Herm @ 20/2/2021 19:47

Cody @ 21/2/2021 1:45 So we think this started with 3 Indians and 3 Pakistans? No recruiter ?? 3 Pakistanis, 3 Indians and 1 Arsonist that could be recruited into the Pakistani Mafia. If there was an actual Cult Recruiter on top of this, the game would be super unbalanced lol. Badger vs Rodney felt like scum on scum lol.

so both had 3 but one could get to 4? have to think on the balance of abilities.

Cody @ 20/2/2021 19:49

I don’t know. We haven’t seen any proof other than the little wording in Badgers role. And if Rodney’s is being truthful his full role. It makes sense that maybe only Badger coukd be recruited and Rodney role is to just stop that? What makes you think Badger vs Rodney was scum on scum

a role thats only purpose is to prevent a single player from being recruited?

Cody @ 20/2/2021 20:37

Gabagool @ 20/2/2021 17:36 TT is most likely scum. I did block him LN though. I guess unless I was redirected.

by who? i guess my knowing im telling the truth reduces the possibilities but how does this work? it assumes there are 2 scum left and a specific role when there being 2 scum on its own explains it.

Herm @ 20/2/2021 21:36

I do feel like that only Badger was the one who could be recruited, I don't think there's anything else to it. But this is just me throwing out theories.

Herm @ 20/2/2021 21:47

Cult + Arsonist + 3 person Indian team + Ahoda's team? 17 person game. There's too many scum in this theory.

maybe Spin originally had a cult but there were not enough players to keep it? but he left the part about Badger being recruit able in, on purpose or by accident? i mean if there is recruiting its important that 3rd party know if they can be recruited.

i mean i have contributed a tiny bit since i said that. also we have lynched scum 2 days in a row and Timmah had good shots so i would say my plan is working great. what faction would i even make sense as? or are you saying i was recruited?

Herm @ 21/2/2021 10:56

Tattered Tooth @ 21/2/2021 16:19 BTW, the way Maddie barely commits to lynches still looks more scummy to me. Also: if Spin can give Rodney that alleged role without any recruitment happening, I wouldn't be surprised if we have only Curtis (maybe Timmah because of wording) as vanilla with farlig role. If Rodney is scum, it's a fake claim. Badger could be recruited so we know it's a thing.

i mean he could have been if there was recruiting in play.

Gabagool @ 21/2/2021 13:21

I think it's either TT or Rod, idk.

good news for you. it cant be TT alone because Cody blocked him. bad news for you is it could still be TT and someone else.

as for me i have no idea what to do today other then not lynching Timmah(killed both scum teams)/Cody(not willing to lynch him today with a confirmed block on TT)/TT (was blocked)

so i guess its Rodney/Maddie/Herm for me today. if it is actually Cody+TT then i give up

i think i have further narrowed down my options to just Herm or Maddie. someone sell me on either or them

Tattered Tooth @ 21/2/2021 16:14

Has been for a while, heh. I'm not sure yet... But I stated on my other post that it could be 317 or Rod.

its not me. in fact

##lynch Maddie

ooh Maddie that vote on TT looks bad. unless he is scum with Cody he cant have killed last night.

not totally opposed to Rodney but i kind of feel like why would he counter Badger as scum?

Herm @ 21/2/2021 18:16

Reading im317's posts, if he was town wouldn't he have been more helpful? His post seem to be hitting the nail on the head several times. (I assume that's how you say it).

more helpful how?

i feel like there is a subtle push to move the vote to Rodney and it has me worried that there is recruitment and there very close to winning

Herm @ 21/2/2021 18:22

im317 @ 22/2/2021 0:17 Herm @ 21/2/2021 18:16 Reading im317's posts, if he was town wouldn't he have been more helpful? His post seem to be hitting the nail on the head several times. (I assume that's how you say it). more helpful how? discussing theories, knowledge from previous games etc. You nailed it on the Arsonist thing early on lol.

i would have to be around more to do that and that would take effort. plus sometimes people scum read me for focusing on the mechanics.

Herm @ 21/2/2021 18:24

If there is recruitment, it means Pakistani Mafia can recruit + kill. I don't think it could be another faction, because that means we have a Cult and a Mafia left lmao.

i mean only Ahdoa has flipped and he was the forced killer. if anything forcing a faction to use a specific person to do all there kills is a negative modifier. what kind of positive do they get to counter that? limited recruitment?

Cody @ 21/2/2021 18:28

It needs in 35 min? Lord Where. Is. Timmah.

weekends Timmah is limited or not active

again this push to vote Rodney. has me worried people are trying to force me to vote him to save myself and lose the game

i mean i still dont see Rodney countering Badger as scum. if he did he almost deserves to live another day