Rose, did you kill Sock? And Sock killed Spin? Who killed Paul?

##Assign Zach The Virgin

Okay so.. I have a theory.

Well, I've been kinda hesitant because idk if it's that big but I don't think the fake gun was meant for Kat. So, js that doesn't auto-clear her from being mafia. It doesn't mean she is mafia either (hence why I'm saying it might not be big news lol), but if she didn't know it was the fake gun she got, the fact she used it on non-mafia means she could be mafia.

Let me know if that's not clear lol.

Shadow @ 24/10/2018 22:31

Also the flip at the end of the last day confirmed investigative roles exist

idk if it confirms for sure but they could exist - I think when Spin was Miller in ATTWS his role probably had something about how he would investigate on reports. But it as all a ruse.

Jackie @ 24/10/2018 22:37

##assign JJ The Principle

Thank you! There were 3 I thought I might get and didn't want. This makes me happy lol.

JJ @ 24/10/2018 22:37

Jackie @ 24/10/2018 22:37 ##assign JJ The Principle Thank you! There were 3 I thought I might get and didn't want. This makes me happy lol.

well inb4 it doesn't

Jackie @ 24/10/2018 22:37

maf took a hit, good to see. Does the person who used Brian's role want to come forward?

Oh duh I forgot about that. So that's how Paul got killed probably...

Mittens @ 24/10/2018 22:35

JJ @ 24/10/2018 21:30 Well, I've been kinda hesitant because idk if it's that big but I don't think the fake gun was meant for Kat. So, js that doesn't auto-clear her from being mafia. It doesn't mean she is mafia either (hence why I'm saying it might not be big news lol), but if she didn't know it was the fake gun she got, the fact she used it on non-mafia means she could be mafia. Let me know if that's not clear lol. I have no reason to believe it wasn’t meant for Kat, but if that’s the case then you make a good point.

I have reason to believe because she got something meant for Primate so, I think the fake gun was also meant for Primate.

Shadow @ 24/10/2018 22:40

Christian could have given scum buddy Kat a fake gun knowing it would make her look good if he died before her. But I still think with all that’s hapoening to her and her Jamie lynch she looks more so good

Possibly, but it wouldn't be the first time mafia voted for each other.

Vic @ 24/10/2018 22:54

The amount of bad things that have happened to Kat so far make me think she's town

You're not getting what I'm saying.

She got an item that is making bad things happen to her. I gave that to Primate N1 (it was my only action) but she somehow got it. The reason I gave it to Primate was because he lynched Tricks D1 and I thought he might be trying to save Ahoda, by lynching Tricks. Obviously Primate was town and I think Ahoda is town now.

She got the fake gun so, if actions used on Primate were redirected to her (I know this had to have happened), then the fake gun was meant for Primate.

The blood on her hands was from Rose and that is not indicative of Kat's alignment.

Also, Kat failed to talk about having the blood on her hands or getting anything besides that gun until questioned further.

Again, it doesn't mean she's not town, necessarily, but the "bad things that happened to her" do not make her town because 2/3 were not even meant for her. The third was from Rose, who I think is town.

I wanted this out there in case I'm gone (it's D5, I don't usually last much longer) and people keep assuming mafia gave Kat a fake gun and just saying she's cleared because of it.

Yeah, she could definitely be town. But, she hasn't posted much or really scum-hunted - could be just because she's busy and new to this. I'm just saying that there is a question and I'd rather have that info out there just in case.

Give Vic The Survivor. I wish I could assign all of these.

Revised list...

Town
JJ
Ahoda
Brian
Mike
Rose
Shadow

Lean Town
Henry
TiB - it's just a vibe but I almost put him in neutral - I think TIB blends in and looks helpful until he gets heat when he's scum so could go either way
Vic - almost a town because he was so insistent Herm was town but.. he's also really good when he's scum so I moved him down a tier

Neutral
Ari - meh
Kat - not sold on town anymore but not sold on scum so she goes here
Kenny - I usually think I know if he's scum but he's also not very active so not sure
Jackie - She kind of plays the same as town/scum from what I've seen
Merc - I probably have him too high tbh
Nav - I had town vibes before but he's also really good as scum so I can't put him any higher
Shawn - idk he's also good as scum (this is getting redundant)
Timmah - I can never tell with him so he's neutral
Zach - I moved him up because his activity level improved D4 but maybe he should still go lower

Third Party
im317

Lean Scum
Darkus - moved him up from scum just because he was going after Spin, except he was still doing it in a trolly way and I could still see him doing that as scum
Mittens - nothing to really make him higher but nothing to put him in "scum" category yet

Scum
Boc - Hasn't added anything at all, just coasting
Havo - idk
Vern - probably scum

Too many question marks right now

##lynch Boc

come play