San Juan
Winner: 10/10 - LOVE Natalie, she deserved it and played great.
Entertainment: 8/10 - I tend to like seasons more in general when my favorite is winning :P
Cast: 8/10 -
Gameplay: 9/10

Australia
Winner: 3/10 - nice lady but never liked her as a winner
Entertainment: 6/10 - It was fun until Skupin's accident flipped the game and the wrong tribe ended up on top. Kucha was WAY more likable than Ogakor in general imo and it was so sad to lose Varner pre-jury and then Elisabeth, Rodger basically not having a shot to win due to #s.
Cast: 6/10
Gameplay: 6/10

I think that's what it is - I really like the strategy side but I also love Natalie and that's a big part of it. I don't think it has to do as much with whether someone is a "die-hard" fan or not and that's up for interpretation anyway. Just like opinions, they're not all going to be the same.