First of all, Tim. I'm not scum. Explain your vote.

Second, why would Dylan protect Rose unless she's also third party?

Boc @ 12/4/2014 21:40

Buffy @ 12/4/2014 21:39 First of all, Tim. I'm not scum. Explain your vote. Second, why would Dylan protect Rose unless she's also third party? Dylan wasn't third party when he sent in his action last night

How do you know that? I've re-read this three times. It's also confusing that it shows Rose survived an attacked in the middle of Dylan's flavor.

Tim @ 12/4/2014 21:45

Since we aren't allowed to claim roles in this game, it's pretty much impossible for anyone here to prove that they aren't scum or that they are town. I mean usually someone could claim, and then be counter-claimed and voila, but here we can't even insinuate can we? I mean, does Boc saying Drrr might be BP count as fishing? What is an isn't allowed? It's very murky. Really we have nothing to go on and will inevitably just have to pick someone randomly to lynch every day while being killed off at night. I mean if there's a role that can out a scum, that person can't out the scum because that's claiming a role. So I will simply be sticking with Buffy every day until eventually people join the train. There's nothing else to do but join someone else's train. They're all, in the end, random trains. Though Buffy is suspicious, as is Matt.

Matt is dead and was town, how is he suspicious lol? And how am I suspicious? And why would is your behaviour - sticking with your day 1 vote based on nothing, despite any real evidence which may arise, not suspicious?

Also, you can claim roles just not characters.

Tim @ 12/4/2014 21:53

Jesus fucking Christ stop attacking me and please focus on lynching scum.

You must've read A Christmas Peril.

Vernon of 2014 @ 12/4/2014 21:57

Buffy are you against Tim just because he's against you? That's not very helpful.

I'm against his saying I'm scum for no reason and continuing with his Day 1 malarkey oh Great Scum Hunter. (:

Tim @ 12/4/2014 22:01

Vernon of 2014 @ 12/4/2014 21:57 Tim who are you top 3 suspects? You have been very vocal. Perhaps you could be the apprentice to the scum killer. 1.) there's a scum killer? 2.) there's an apprentice? Like Mickey Mouse? How would you have such information?

Interesting that you immediately think of a "sorcerer's apprentice." Very dicey.

Tim @ 12/4/2014 22:03

Buffy @ 12/4/2014 22:02 Tim @ 12/4/2014 22:01 Vernon of 2014 @ 12/4/2014 21:57 Tim who are you top 3 suspects? You have been very vocal. Perhaps you could be the apprentice to the scum killer. 1.) there's a scum killer? 2.) there's an apprentice? Like Mickey Mouse? How would you have such information? Interesting that you immediately think of a "sorcerer's apprentice." Very dicey. And what exactly does the word apprentice make you think of?

A carpenter's apprentice.

Curtis @ 12/4/2014 22:05

The flavor and role confused me but after reading it a few times, it seems fairly clear to me that Dyl chose Rose, he was attacked causing Rose to be attacked, and Rose only survived because she was either protected by someone or something else. I'm pretty sure Rose surviving has nothing to do with Dylan Tbh I think she's likely some form of BP. We've already got Jordan's lover and Dylan as two doctor types. Another Doctor being out there and happening to protect Rose on this same night is possible but less likely I think

She seemed to be indicating she's not BP.

Why Can't I Hold All These Greens @ 12/4/2014 22:08

Buffy @ 12/4/2014 22:07 Curtis @ 12/4/2014 22:05 The flavor and role confused me but after reading it a few times, it seems fairly clear to me that Dyl chose Rose, he was attacked causing Rose to be attacked, and Rose only survived because she was either protected by someone or something else. I'm pretty sure Rose surviving has nothing to do with Dylan Tbh I think she's likely some form of BP. We've already got Jordan's lover and Dylan as two doctor types. Another Doctor being out there and happening to protect Rose on this same night is possible but less likely I think She seemed to be indicating she's not BP. Don is BP and why would she indicate that?

I don't know why, she just did. She thinks someone protected her.

Okay so Dylan was recruited but, before he was recruited, he chose Rose to protect and because she was attacked, he died. So, her surviving has nothing to do with his protection. It was either some type of other protection or BP.

drrr @ 12/4/2014 22:14

I'm not BP. That's why I'm confused! I received results last night, so it wasn't a jailing. I don't get it at all.

I'm pretty sure a jailing wouldn't show in the flavor.

drrr @ 12/4/2014 22:17

Buffy @ 12/4/2014 23:13 Okay so Dylan was recruited but, before he was recruited, he chose Rose to protect and because she was attacked, he died. So, her surviving has nothing to do with his protection. It was either some type of other protection or BP. No, because he was attacked, I was attacked. If I'd just been attacked and he wasn't, I would have been protected.

Okay, you're right, it says if he's attacked the same night he protects someone both will die. So, you survived despite his role somehow.

Curtis @ 12/4/2014 22:17

Buffy @ 12/4/2014 22:15 drrr @ 12/4/2014 22:14 I'm not BP. That's why I'm confused! I received results last night, so it wasn't a jailing. I don't get it at all. I'm pretty sure a jailing wouldn't show in the flavor. That's not what she's saying. She's ruling out jailing as a possibility for her protection because she wasn't roleblocked, and jailing equals protection + roleblock

Okay, I understand what you're saying. But, I just thought it was obvious jailing wouldn't be a possibility for her protection anyway since it wouldn't show.

drrr @ 12/4/2014 22:20

Buffy @ 12/4/2014 23:15 drrr @ 12/4/2014 22:14 I'm not BP. That's why I'm confused! I received results last night, so it wasn't a jailing. I don't get it at all. I'm pretty sure a jailing wouldn't show in the flavor. I'm talking about a standard jailer, not an interceptor. Jailers roleblock and protect their target. Interceptors block all actions on that person, but leave that person free to use their role. An interceptor wouldn't show in the flavor. I never would have been attacked, and Dylan never could have protected me. A jailing would roleblock me, and protect me like a doctor would, and would show a survival in the flavor. But it doesn't make sense because my role worked last night.

A jailing would show in the flavor?

I tend to agree with Greenday here. I don't think Rose is that easily confused and her survival points to BP which she is not claiming.

##Lynch Drr