Clark Griswold @ 8/12/2013 22:45

fyi, I have a long day of travel ahead of me tomorrow.

I guess I can kinda see Justin voting for someone besides FF to call attention to the fact that he wasn't on the train of a townie later, but meh. It'd make more sense just to not vote for anyone instead of drawing attention to yourself with a joke lynch like that

I'm looking at Jeff the most right now. His "wow quick train!!" was really scummy to me. Such a typical thing to say to cast suspicion on everyone on a train, a train which probably didn't even have any scum on it (maybe 1-2 at most). It's basically calling them all scum without actually saying it outright. ALSO his reaction to my vote on him seemed a little scummy to me too

SO FOR NOW

##lynch Jeff

Nobert @ 8/12/2013 23:22

Boc @ 9/12/2013 0:06 I guess I can kinda see Justin voting for someone besides FF to call attention to the fact that he wasn't on the train of a townie later, but meh. It'd make more sense just to not vote for anyone instead of drawing attention to yourself with a joke lynch like that I'm looking at Jeff the most right now. His "wow quick train!!" was really scummy to me. Such a typical thing to say to cast suspicion on everyone on a train, a train which probably didn't even have any scum on it (maybe 1-2 at most). It's basically calling them all scum without actually saying it outright. ALSO his reaction to my vote on him seemed a little scummy to me too SO FOR NOW ##lynch Jeff oh men your joke lynch always turns to silly real attempts at lynching me every game! (: You're wrong almost every time too! I think I might go for Simp vote as well. Earthbound expressed my thots on his silly post. ##lynch: Simp For now

1. It wasn't a joke lynch, I thought I made that pretty clear!
2. Stop acting scummy every game then (:

I'd like to hear YOUR reasons for voting Simp though. Right now it just looks like you're bandwagoning on the first train you can

Nobert @ 8/12/2013 23:22

oh men your joke lynch always turns to silly real attempts at lynching me every game! (: You're wrong almost every time too!

ALSO BECAUSE I WAS CURIOUS AND LITERALLY HAVE NOTHING BETTER TO DO (like studying)

The games where I was town and you also played:

Summer Camp Mafia: you were Mafia Godfather and were lynched D1, and I actually defended you (:
Bot Mafia: you were town, I didn't vote for you
Dirty Syringe: you were town, I voted for you
Lottery Mafia: you were mafia, I voted for you
Snowman Mafia: you were mafia, I didn't vote for you
Quarantine Mafia: you were mafia, I voted for you
Dead Zone Mafia: you were town, I didn't vote for you
Hardcore Mafia 2: you were town, I didn't vote for you

so that's 2/3 success rate when I vote for you, not exactly wrong almost every time (:

Simplton @ 9/12/2013 0:52

Sorry I'm used to java based and webcam based mafia. Not sure I've really gotten down and dirty in forum mafia. Trying to gather a strategy and thoughts in forum mafia. Hard to read someone when they have hours to formulate a post and thought.

Alternately it gives you way more of an opportunity to build cases since everything said is static

No lynches are the dumbest thing ever

Simplton @ 9/12/2013 1:13

You're telling the guy with over 6 years of mafia experience. I know what's good for the town and what isn't.

looooooooooooooooool

i'm crying

Simplton @ 9/12/2013 1:20

You guys are making it seem like lynching FF was the godsend town needed and we are all enlightened now. Let's take all this great info we gathered and lynch a mafia. Oh wait...I'm not seeing it because you idiots are tunneling me like always. You think you guys would learn? Stubborn people.

We're trying Corey we're trying!!!!!

There's been 3 different leads brought up today from the FF train (Justin/Jeff/you)

0 from the Nofo/Matt deaths

You didn't really "blow up" until you got called out tbh

Simplton @ 9/12/2013 1:37

Boc @ 9/12/2013 1:31 You didn't really "blow up" until you got called out tbh Only out of the stubbornness and feeling like you guys have no idea where I'm coming from. Look at it from my point of view. Is it really worth risking hitting the cop, medic, orc, vig, etc? Just to see people's lynches on D1 where there is next to no basis? Yes it may help late game SLIGHTLY but I think the bad heavily outweighs the good.

Option 1: no lynch and have virtually nothing to go off of on D2, effectively making it a de facto D1
Option 2: lynch someone and gain information based on who voted for them, who voted for someone else, who didn't vote at all, etc. Best case scenario you hit scum, worst case you might take out a power role (although hopefully they'd claim if that was the case) but get the ball rolling information-wise nevertheless.

And I wasn't even really in favor of the FF train. I hate inactives, but I rarely vote for them. I always try to go for who I think is acting scummy on D1 even if there's hardly anything to go on. BUT with that said I think lynching FF was a FAR better alternative to a no lynch any day. It's just unfortunate that he had a decent role (one which he might've never been around to use)

Paco @ 9/12/2013 7:01

I think Simp is just being Simp. Same with Jeff. What I am looking at is the fast pile of votes on ff yesterday for no reason. It was quite obvious he wasn't going to show up and I think a few mafia rode that train to ensure a townie lynch.

Earthbound already kinda covered this, but this doesn't make any sense to me. Plurality was on yesterday and the "biggest" trains besides the FF one all had a single vote each. There was no reason for that to be a mafia-led train. There might've been 1-2 on there but that's about it

I think the people who didn't vote are much better suspects. Like Jeff, who as I said before sat back and tried to subtly cast suspicion on everyone while offering nothing of his own

AND

earlier in the day I asked for some kind, ANY kind of explanation for Jeff's bandwagon vote on Simp, in his own words. He didn't say anything. Then later when the Greenday train pops up, Jeff immediately jumps on and says "o I think simp is town now"

Either incredibly dumb or incredibly scummy, but I'm leaning towards the latter

I'm guessing it'll mean only one of you can be lynched. But I guess we'll soon see

Well you'd be kinda fucked because I don't see how Panda wouldn't be town with a role like that (:

Nobert @ 9/12/2013 13:44

Yeah I don't know what else to do but claim and I'm not willing to do that based on Boc's suspicion on me, there's nothing ever to go by on day 1 so I almost have nothing much to offer, anyone could say "that train was fast" and could be town or mafia". I think Boc is just determined to believe I'm scum but I'm not.

Or maybe you could explain why you bandwagoned on Simp, then IMMEDIATELY did a 180 and proclaimed him as town as soon as the Greenday train started up and you then bandwagoned on that.