I think Nofo was straight third party. I don't think that the killer is necessarily mafia, since there two kills on night two and none of the mafia we've lynched have had an extra kill. It's possible that there's still a ninja role out there, but I'm more inclined to think it was a vig or a very silent third party SK.

For now I still see Patrick as the most suspicious, but I'm interested to see what others have to say.

Well, let's not forget that usurpers usually scan as vanilla after taking over for the Don. It's a pretty standard role for a game this size, and I don't recall one showing up among the ones we've killed.

Paco @ 29/12/2013 11:49

Vic I would like yo hear your claim since you're pretty much the only person we gave virtually no information about. Everyone else still alive has either claimed or been scanned as town by Justin.

As we've pointed out several times, usurper and SK would both scan as town.

I'm torn between Patrick who seems to have given up, and has the epically suspicious double roleclaim factor, and Paco who seems pretty desperate to have everybody convinced that Justin's scan exonerates him.

Either lynch would probably tell us quite a bit.