JOsh being scum doesn't feel right.

If josh is scum...

1. Why did Dadd vote josh during the Patrick lynch. That vote was so close and could've gone either way.
2. Why would josh out Herm visiting Canuck on the night he was unlynchable

Mads @ 10/2/2018 14:56

Distancing? I don't know... The only other option is Primate and I reeeeeally don't think it's him.

Primate didn't break you and Buffy up either maddie :3

Primate @ 10/2/2018 14:58

ZacharyB @ 10/2/2018 12:55 If josh is scum... 1. Why did Dadd vote josh during the Patrick lynch. That vote was so close and could've gone either way. 2. Why would josh out Herm visiting Canuck on the night he was unlynchable Why would a mafia role thief visit another mafia in the first place. Was canuck some sort of traitor who started as town?

Herm probably had another ability to make someone unlynchable.

IDk. I mean y'all can lynch Josh if you want but I don't feel it

Mads @ 10/2/2018 14:58

Zach why would a watcher still be alive this stage in the game?

Maybe because people have been saying he's scum all game so they'd want him as a possible mislynch?

Mads @ 10/2/2018 15:05

Primate @ 10/2/2018 15:04 I read the end of yesterday thinking d's had to be scum, but no. Mafia should have left him alive. Can you imagine how hard it would have been to convince DS to vote the right way today? Mafia actually helped us out. Seems like Zach is taking his place though!

Don't get sassy maddie

Mads @ 10/2/2018 15:06

ZacharyB @ 10/2/2018 15:05 Mads @ 10/2/2018 14:58 Zach why would a watcher still be alive this stage in the game? Maybe because people have been saying he's scum all game so they'd want him as a possible mislynch? Not at final five when scum can be uncovered by process of elimination with a watcher's info in the game.

Idk, I've always hated the "why is this PR alive" argument. I've seen so many games where PRs live longer than they should after they've claimed.

Let's see who he watched. If it's someone ridiculous maybe I'll buy in.

Also, do you guys think we had two townies trying to find people?

I haven't checked this thread since I posted Joshua

If the thread refreshed its because I was opening chrome on my phone to look up when 1984 was released or because I was looking up the run time of The Red Turtle (beautiful movie btw)

I will be more active later today, sorry for going away yesterday y'all.

Josh @ 10/2/2018 16:17

I'd like to hear more from Zach today. I don't trust him having a silencing and protective/role-blocking role.

Interesting that you're only saying this now, not when I claimed it days ago (:

Hmmmmmm

The Sebneet @ 11/2/2018 14:23

Bisson, how would you handle a Watcher+Commuter. What results would the Watcher get.

Watcher should get no results. A commuter is untargetable, meaning that anyone who targets them is effectively blocked.

https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Commuter

I get the flavor argument of, oh, you go to their house so you should see everyone else there. But functionally speaking, if you target a commuter, you are roleblocked.

Hey Josh, I don't know if you thought suddenly pushing me was a good idea because I've been inactive all day

But I'm back now hun (: (: (:

Why do you think I'm scum? Because this is very sudden and you haven't brought up me being scum like .. at all this game. But now that you're in the hot seat and other people are mentioning my name, I'm your go to lynch.

INTERESTING! (: (: (: