yeah, I opted to no kill because I don't have a good idea who scum is atm. I was going to shoot brian because he's the last of the sort of non verifiable roles, but he gives me town vibes if I'm being honest.

itsbrianyay @ 8/5/2017 21:19

except that i should be the last person you'd consider shooting since i literally cannot be scum unless spin is scum with me

can you please not newb shame me

is the game over

6/10

Dylan was definitely the better actor I genuinely believed that he thought he was dead

Zersch @ 8/5/2017 22:24

I guess you all missed where I said "you did good, kid". It takes years to perfect dialogue like that.

That bumped your performance from a 4 to a 6.

spin who'd u redirect

I'd assume since the night PMs haven't mentioned they can't that they can do their kill and action at the same time, no?

Atm I think scum has to be Dylan or spin. Dylan's reaction to the daykill was kind of scummy imo!!!

Spin being a backup would make sense since he took no action N1, and cherry died D2, would also explain why he redirected me when I was very clearly aiming at the GF the night he did so.

I think you or dyl are scum because I can't see any other person here being scum. A scum nurse that activates once the town doc dies makes no sense, and a scum inventor who gave no items to scum (and more importantly, gave a day kill to the most competent townie) makes no sense.

You shooting DS makes sense from a town perspective, but it also makes a Fuck ton of sense from a scum one.

And in spins defense, there being a town and scum redirect makes sense since there was a town and scum investigator.

We know Josh is a nurse from Jamie's visit. A nurse is a backup doctor traditionally. We're yet to see any role flips where the role hasn't been it's like...established role function. So I'm pretty comfortable saying josh is a back up doc.

If you have a theory about what a scum nurse could be when we didn't have a scum doctor, I'd love to hear it. But just posing a bunch of questions and muddying the waters is doing no one any favors.

Josh @ 9/5/2017 13:06

Hello. I apologize for being away, I was on THE NEWS. How exciting. My thoughts in the next post.

If you posted that on D2, I would've assumed being on the news was some sort of night action

Sorry if you've answered this, but who left alive have you not redirected spin?