I'm about 100% sure at this point that the every-other-night night kill increases have been a vigilante at this point. And while I'm not 100% sure about Dylan being scum, given my history this game that's almost a sure confirmation that he is.

##lynch Dylan

I want to hear what he has to say for himself, so let's not let it get to the hammer point today.

The suspicion against Natalie was entirely that she didnt seem to be getting any attention. I really don't think it was a surprising target. Someone trusted-ish, active and who was less likely to be protected.

It wasn't just that, it was how Dylan and Wikey vouched for each other the day before and how even when it got down to the wire, they were not on each other's trains until it had tied. They were both getting a lot of heat but didn't go for each other. Then Dylan cut the conversation short by hammering.

This:

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 23/2/2013 22:19

It wasn't just that, it was how Dylan and Wikey vouched for each other the day before and how even when it got down to the wire, they were not on each other's trains until it had tied. They were both getting a lot of heat but didn't go for each other. Then Dylan cut the conversation short by hammering.

was in response to this:

Curtis @ 23/2/2013 22:17

tbh I don't think Dylan's slip up yesterday was scummy really. I think it was just a mistake

Alive (11)
Ari
Curtis
Drr
Dylan
Justin
Kiwi
Korr
Leaffan20
LSFIssue
Rito
Shawn

I forgot Justin and Ari were in this.... and LSFissue.

Dylan @ 23/2/2013 22:26

Sorry for yesterday pals! I only read the lynch part and not the do what I say an not what I do part.

But you decided to jump aboard without saying anything else?

Nope, I was suspicious of him briefly, but he's posted so little all game overall that I forgot about him

Dylan @ 23/2/2013 22:31

I'm surprised Natalie was town she was on my list of suspicious people? How many mafia people are left. We got Wikey, Greendat Rob and Grim. I haven't played too much but I think we are at 3 mafia members left? LSF is still iffy for me. Kiwi's constant boner for lynching me is getting old but I think he is probably clean. The other two are who knows. Probably not Jeff unless there is also a bullet proof mafia member. Ari has been really quiet since he wanted Malion out so bad

I don't think there would be 3 mafia members left at this point. My guess is 2 left at most for a 20 player game.

I think the only way Jeff is scum is up Grim protected him and they targetted him as part of some silly gambit. But I don't see the point at all. There is almost nothing to suggest there is a SK, and we've gotten the don. Jeff probably got mafia targetted as an easy target and was either truthful about the oneshot BP or was a doctor and protected himself. I keep going over that night but it seems to make the most sense to assume he's town.

Ari going quiet is strange, and I dunno what to think of it. I still think he was being retarded earlier.

LSF is impossible to read because he appears to be clinically retarded.

The others, I dunno

Curtis @ 23/2/2013 22:32

Today basically proves there's no SK I would be surprised if there was no third party at all though. I'm guessing no cult at this point. Maybe a survivor role? Is there any other type of third party I'm not thinking of? It's been bothering me a bit

If there is a SK he hasn't been killing, or he's been posing as a vigilante. There could still be some kind of lovers role out there too, but tbh I think no 3rd party may be the TWIST. We've come to expect it in even the most basic setups. Maybe its just the two factions

I don't see a cult happening at this point with no evidence of it at all, and survivor is an annoying role so I hope there isnt one

Dylan @ 23/2/2013 22:43

Didn't Boc and someone else die in the same night?

There have been 2 attacks every other night. That's usually the sign of a vigilante who isn't allowed to kill on consecutive nights. It's usually not a limitation given to SKs (their limitation is sometimes that they HAVE to kill each night). It's always possible that a SK doesn't have any limitation like that here and is killing every other night as a vigilante to disprove its own existence, but that is a huge stretch.

Kiwi @ 23/2/2013 22:46

Curtis @ 24/2/2013 16:41 Since Natalie was killed it all but clears Kiwi Lol'd. Um could one of Nat's invention's backfired?

But then who would the mafia's target have been? There has to be at least one left (or a 3rd party) for the game to be continuing. Unless the last bot left is inactive, then maybe.

But most likely, Natalie was the mafia's target last night and it had nothing to do with her role.

How the hell does Rito have 25 posts on day 4. I would have guessed 5 at the most...

Quote

Dylan defended me? ## in lunch Wikey ## lynch Dulan

Anyway, he was hovering between Wikey or Dylan for the vote. AS MUCH AS I PUSHED THIS EARLIER IN THE GAME I don't think he's scum at this point. Just retarded. He lynched Dylan and unlynched Wikey long before the tie issue came up. Jeff is the only one that added on to Dylan's lynch train during that mess and everyone else stood strong besides Wikey hopping about 5 different trains.

I still feel like the lynch tying was a happy fluke for the scum and not a deliberate move. Though it tied at the very last possible second, so maybe it was something that was being held back for the last possible moment. It still felt like Wikey was just flailing about wildly and happened to accidentally save himself

The consistency of the kills, 1, 2, 1, 2, 1 makes me think it's probably a vig. None of the multi-kill nights could have possibly been a PGO at all.

Wikey and then either Boc or Henry were probably vigilante targets.

I don't think LSFissue even comprehended why there was a lynch on Wikey. He just jumped on. But it's so hard to get a read on, because he's a complete idiot.

Kiwi @ 23/2/2013 23:46

Curtis can you do an investigation into Dylan like you did into Wikey?

Huh?