Lamps how dare you

Hi checking in between classes so can't say much. I've mostly caught up though

Lamps's survival isnt that suspicious really. Night 1 there are a lot of reasons for someone to survive. The REACTION is really interesting though. It seems like a lot of pushing in both directions. The meta about survivals at FE always being scum is seeing off some red flags for me. Survivals usually get heat, but the reason so many we lynch flip scum is because we usually lynch when there's a good chance they are scum.

Also how often Lamps is the N1 target? I'm remembering Sherlock mafia and maybe one other before or after that, but otherwise I dunno. Can't check now tho

Dadd @ 28/4/2016 11:12

It seems cold hearted ... but if a Doc heals himself on N1 and gets hit ... his role is kind of ruined, no?

Not if he isn't lynched or forced to claim. (:

This post seems really BAD to me. Not cold-hearted bad, more like trying to set up a justification ahead of time.

vladykins @ 28/4/2016 11:13

Angi @ 28/4/2016 10:03 Timmah @ 28/4/2016 10:03 This is really pretty interesting. In 99.9% of the games over here, when someone survives a kill and there is not an accounted for reason, they get lynched. And about 90% of the time, they flip scum of some fashion. And rarely is there much push back from more than the person who survived and maybe 1-2 others. Contrast to this game, where Lamps survives a kill attempt and has 5-6 people defending him pretty damn hard. Strange, because the last like five games I've played in here, everyone bitches if we target someone who survives a kill. Sometimes they're scum, sometimes they're bullet proof, sometimes they're the fucking doctor I've played two here, ATTWS VI and Fallout IV. ATTWS VI had 3/4 when I was still alive scum/total survivor (Vini, Ida, Harry, and Dolly). I forget if Gavin and Silas were outed by failed kill attempts or not- I'd have to go back and look. In Fallout, jay survived (and was outed cult), and Ari was mafia BP.

Jay didn't survive because he was cult. He survived because he was protected, and he was cult because he was recruited. Both happened because of his role, but one didn't happen because of the other. It's a weird thing to use as backup.

ATTWS Harry was never attacked. Which makes it 2/3. I wouldn't cout Vini either, since that was a scum planned move after Vinicio had already claimed BP. It's not really in the same category.

So all of that is very weird to meta off of.