My only other guess would be Shadow at this point.

Why would you shoot PENNER of all people

After Mittens flipped scum, I feel like Penner was pretty clearly town. And same with Moose flipping scum about me. I feel like you just went for the most vocal town to try and run today, Star.

Jackie has to be cleared whether Shadow is lying or not. If Shadow is being honest about his role then Jackie is 100% town, and if Shadow is lying.. It still makes Jackie town because we would have lost coming in to today.

But, I think Star being an anti-hero makes the most sense here.

I think taking the kill out of the equation is the safest, even though I think you're the only person that would make sense being the last anti-hero.

Shadow @ 15/10/2020 14:47

Okay I’m at work so bear with me but I promise I’m not scum here and I’m very confused. I didn’t use my power because I literally had no idea why the game didn’t end and between Josh and Star I didn’t want to die and end the game for town

I feel like using your action today is the best call? You either town confirm someone or you can say who you're checking, and if you die -- we know who the scum is.

Stargate @ 15/10/2020 14:49

Josh O'Lantern @ 15/10/2020 14:46 I think taking the kill out of the equation is the safest, even though I think you're the only person that would make sense being the last anti-hero. Are you an Anti-Hero doctor, for reals, Josh? If not for their being a Jailkeeper you would've went unsussed. How is Town supposed to catch an Anti-Hero Doctor who is healing townie people and themselves on the other nights? It makes sense to me that you'd be Town over Penner.

I'm town doctor still. I don't think the anti-heroes having a doctor would make much sense, especially with what roles have flipped for them so far.

Shadow @ 15/10/2020 14:52

Josh O'Lantern @ 15/10/2020 14:49 Shadow @ 15/10/2020 14:47 Okay I’m at work so bear with me but I promise I’m not scum here and I’m very confused. I didn’t use my power because I literally had no idea why the game didn’t end and between Josh and Star I didn’t want to die and end the game for town I feel like using your action today is the best call? You either town confirm someone or you can say who you're checking, and if you die -- we know who the scum is. Yeah I might have to. It’s obviously just one left. Are we to assume anti hero or scum ?

I'm almost positive it's just an anti-hero left. There was only one kill last night from Star and I can't imagine scum would NK this late in the game with a doctor still alive.

Stargate @ 15/10/2020 14:57

If you're telling the truth Shadow, I say do it on Josh, and you should die from that. And then Jackie and I can vote Josh out. If you do it on one of us and live then it's not really changing much info wise cause you could be lying.

You're saying that because Shadow is going to use it on me and live, and you'll just start trying to lynch Shadow instead. (:

You're welcome to use it on me, Shadow. You will live and we can lynch Star together. <3

Unless you want to use it on Star just to confirm that he's scum, but I know the thought of sacrificing yourself probably isn't the most appealing.

hi zersch man. love u. miss u.

Stargate @ 15/10/2020 15:02

Josh O'Lantern @ 15/10/2020 15:01 You're welcome to use it on me, Shadow. You will live and we can lynch Star together. <3 If you're this confident then it's Shadow.

I'm very confident that I'm town. :yay: Why would I go out of my way to save important town roles if I was an Anti-Hero?

Honestly, I'm just upset you killed Penner so he can't do this town work for me. I was hoping I could rely on him carry town to victory while I watched Bly Manor.

I almost saved Penner but I figured that if you were scum, you'd go for someone more UTR.