These roles are pretty creative.

Sup spin?

DsssssssS @ 26/12/2017 21:35

If patrick didnt get killed im guessing we would have had a cult or something?

Possible formation of the in-laws stopped?

Did we hear of a message being received yesterday during the extra long day or only today after the second person came forward?

Spin buying a day? Noted.

Votes piling on. Information saying you are guilty. And you have to ask if you should claim?

Delay tactic noted.

Questions on spin from least suspicious to most suspicious:

1) Would he know he is a Miller? Mod’s call so not much weight.
2) Why would he think his and nofo’s roles couldn’t coexist? Not exactly a small game and with some creativity behind this game the mods could have needed them to balance things. Seems like too little to rely on this early for such a big push on nofo.
3) Why not claim today when it’s apparent you look bad? A Miller isn’t exactly high on the list of targets for nightly kills.
4) His style of play seems to fit what Patrick was searching for. Would a Miller mason make sense?

Lamps @ 27/12/2017 9:06

Delay for what? There are like 12 hours remaining until the deadline.

Lamps you’ve played too many mafia games to ask such blatantly obvious questions that really should be rhetorical.

So now we have to figure out whether we believe there are two parts to your role?

Spin @ 27/12/2017 10:05

Snowflake poker @ 27/12/2017 9:03 So now we have to figure out whether we believe there are two parts to your role? You'll believe it because it's the damn truth.

If this wasn't mafia, I'd believe you.

Helios Garabandia @ 27/12/2017 10:20

Spin @ 27/12/2017 10:00 For those of you too lazy to do anything, I'm Town Miller. I didn't think it likely that there would be two negative town roles in the game, so put that claim with all the other BS Nofo was spewing, and it was an easy choice. I also get to visit one person a night, but I don't know who I'm searching for or what will happen if I find them. My luck, I was searching for Patrick, and now I'm just a damn fool wandering around at night. So far I visited Buffy and Helios. Miller is also a perfect claim for scum to claim, as it gives a reason for why you'd scan anti-Town. Also, why are you claiming Town Miller AND also claiming that you get to visit someone? That's two different roles. And how is your searching role different than what Patrick flipped?

I don't think it's uncommon for searchers to both have searching abilities, right? I'm thinking back to our favorite Scooby Doo search squad that bread crumbed themselves into a VERY early death.

And no spin, you can't point to that game to indicate 2 roles were available to them so it could apply here (:

@Lamps

Were you told you had a visitor?

DsssssssS @ 27/12/2017 13:09

Lamps @ 27/12/2017 6:09 Also I have nothing to hide so I don’t really mind one way or another. I’m PGO. Christian visited me, he died, and it’s not because of HIS role but because of mine. That’s what I make of it since I wasn’t notified of anything.

It was outed in the thread that Christian probably visited Lamps before Lamps claimed. Just looking to re-confirm he was in fact told as being told is mod-specific.

So if Lamps is a 1-shot PGO but did not get a message that he was visited the hosts can't obviously tell him he is now vanilla as that would reveal he was visited even if not by whom.

Should we start auto-lynching Sock on D2 if he is alive? We could do it D1 but that is reserved for Curtis until further notice.

So apparently now people can't have "feelings" on people based upon how they perceive their behavior? Did we stop playing mafia at some point?