Just when I thought I've learned most of the roles a new one services. I don't see any reason not to start with the list and hope the caroler continues to get lucky with who they sing to each night.

So Angi finally addresses ahoda's post and claims to have information. I wouldn't claim yet since Herm and Maddie haven't checked in since ahoda posted.

Wanting to know the result of a unique aspect of the game is suddenly scummy behavior?

itsbrianyay @ 3/12/2016 16:12

It also says something about rewards and penalties possibly stacking. Also why does this matter? I made an assumption that may or may not end up being true, so what? It's weird that so many people are like "I wanna know why Brian has a theory!"

But is it? If we know what the drawbacks of losing a duel is it could keep those with the more useful town PR from potentially dueling. Wanting to know how a unique game mechanic works is not that hard to comprehend.

Color me confused. Brian thinks losing enough duels could lead to death but he is campaigning to duel again? Probably not something scum would do so I'll give him that.

Maddie S. @ 3/12/2016 19:31

Herm @ 3/12/2016 17:28 Maddie, you think Ahoda's making up the you, me or Angi is scum info? I think it's definitely a possibility... it just seems too convenient. But I also totally buy that ahoda is town so I don't know what he'd have to gain by making it up...

Making up that a caroler sang to him or the names he received?

Timmah @ 3/12/2016 20:17

why are we dueling mittens? I get the DS duel, since the message appears to "clear" him. I think town wants town in the duel, though brian's cryptic response to the penalty for losing has a bad taste in my mouth. I am reading that he has elected to let his loss "ride", which perhaps carries a harsher penalty if he either doesn't get back there or gets back and loses. But, it would help the town more if he was super clear about what happens with the loser of the duel.

I couldn't have said I better myself. Withholding information on what you won makes sense. Withholding what happens when you lose? I just don't get it.

Christian @ 4/12/2016 11:42

Since DS received that letter recently, it's most likely someone's day action? Is it possible that a watcher or tracker saw Lamps visit farlig and is also able to send someone else that info? Not sure what to make of the sender's intentions at this point, but farlig might be able to shed some light on that. It does sound kind of like a distraction?

I can't explain someone knowing I was attacked last night but also being able to send a note during the day. However, I was attacked but wasn't told by who. Looks like my friend Lamps carried over a grudge from last game (:

I was hoping not to have to claim until I had time to try and draw out the other killer so thanks DS for ruining that. But yes, I was the town BP.

Helios Garabandia @ 4/12/2016 15:11

Darren Sanders @ 4/12/2016 16:04 Right now the thing working against you is that maddie outed information, and Angi claimed to HAVE information. Angi said she had information, but it was useless to reveal it now, right? I think I'm interpreting that right?

Yes but more so in that it wouldn't help find scum but could prove her role.

Mittens @ 4/12/2016 15:09

Wikey was here earlier but didn't say anything. I'd be curious to see what he has to say about Maddie's info.

That's interesting he chose not to address it. Although his posting today has been off so maybe he cant?

farlig @ 4/12/2016 15:31

Mittens @ 4/12/2016 15:09 Wikey was here earlier but didn't say anything. I'd be curious to see what he has to say about Maddie's info. That's interesting he chose not to address it. Although his posting today has been off so maybe he cant?

Well looking back it started normal but then went weird at some point during the day. Day action or does Wiley post random shit sometimes?

So nothing has changed but Wikey confirming maddie's info? I'd assume spin would put flavor or role cop in her role PM if that's the case but then again spins an ass and maybe wanted her to have to figure it out. I don't see where maddie's ever tried to clarify the name of her role unless I missed it?

Do we want Brian to duel again?