So if Herm is telling the truth (and given the burning of Maddie's results, this is seeming more of a stretch), then there could be multiple RBers out there beyond the town rber, mafia rber. Maybe third party or cult rber? I just don't see the usefulness of a protect somebody from such a small chance- i.e., two rbers and one- maybe more redirectors.

I do want to note that yesterday was the second time that Timmah has gotten attention for surviving and then had us get "distracted" in another direction. Could be coincidence, could be not. Aries flip and Cherry being apparent Vig seems to make Timmah look better, though.

Primate @ 10/4/2017 16:05

vladykins @ 10/4/2017 15:03 So if Herm is telling the truth (and given the burning of Maddie's results, this is seeming more of a stretch), then there could be multiple RBers out there beyond the town rber, mafia rber. Maybe third party or cult rber? I just don't see the usefulness of a protect somebody from such a small chance- i.e., two rbers and one- maybe more redirectors. My first action was a RB on Wikey, so maybe there's a scum version of my role out there?

Having been a mafia JOAT before, that is possible.

I don't see Cherry as SK- it would be pretty risky to CC Aries like that only to be the SK.

spindoctor02 @ 10/4/2017 16:08

Badgerian needs to take Vlady's advice and update the Player list.

:rofl:

Oh- I think it was christian who asked about my voting sock but not voting til later, but then I explained. I'm pretty typical game to game that I don't vote until I'm pretty sure I'm not going to be on again unless its a slam dunk. So I voted Sock when he was obvious and voted Timmah when I was dropping offline yesterday to finish drinking and trying to watch my movie.

Curtis @ 10/4/2017 16:10

jamie ♂ @ 10/4/2017 16:08 Zersch @ 10/4/2017 17:01 Who were you distracted from targeting last night Jamie? I tried to use my action on curtis AY stay off my doorstep!!!!!!! Unless you were trying to help me :$ As far as I'm aware I have nothing to do with distracting people who visit me

I feel like this has come up before in another game, but I don't remember which. Like almost word for word. lol

DS has been online and hasn't said anything, which is Waaaaaaaay out of character, so maybe.

You know it is a good day when 18 posts puts you in the "low posters".

CherryBerry @ 10/4/2017 17:11

I don't feel obligated to announce who I will kill at night or even detail my reasoning for who I pick, and I certainly won't take orders like Curtis attempted yesterday. We haven't solved what's up with the roleblocking and distracting and redirects, so it's absolutely ridiculous to suggest I broadcast who I'll target. What's that part about a SK priming? I've assumed based on the number of deaths that Mafia and I were the only killers.

"Priming" is for a role like arsonist. It's an SK type role that visits people, prepping them for death but not killing them. Then one night, all the primed people get killed in a single blast.

Everyone posted yesterday.

CherryBerry @ 10/4/2017 21:45

Herm @ 10/4/2017 22:40 Angi @ 11/4/2017 0:44 Chris25 @ 10/4/2017 18:41 Angi @ 10/4/2017 18:33 Is it possible to have multiple town bullet proof roles? Angi, theories on why you were silenced a couple days ago but noone has been since? (wow look at me go) Hatred. I'm not smart enough to fucking waste a silencing on. My theory is that silencing is part of a Jack of all Trades role, burning thing is probably part of that role too. This feels plausible. Silencing feels evil. If someone Town successfully blocked a silencer, you would think they'd come forward to identify scum for us.

I guess it could be possible that a silencer was blocked and/or attempted to silence a dead person. I don't think it is worth outing the town RBer to get this info right now.

Herm @ 11/4/2017 8:12

Vlady, you're getting lynch votes.

yeah- I was trying to read through the 20+ pages before I started jumping to conclusions).

I'm curious on Curtis' not cop investigations?

And I'm still not sure I buy the WIFOM "I wouldn't be so obvious if I was scum" argument. I don't know if I'm tainted by the earlier in the game discussion of the Curtis/Ahoda connections, but it all seems real convenient. I wouldn't be surprised to see Curtis flip cult backup recruiter at this point, especially if we had cult but have not, as yet, witnessed an SK.

And if it wasn't likeable Herm doing it, we would have roasted someone who can't seem to get their story straight over two days, especially when the initial claim involves something that would seem marginally useful in a game this large (unless there were a ton of roleblockers/redirectors in the game). I buy Ape's "there might be a few one time RB/RD actions out there" theory, but it still seems off, especially since the unexplained burned note.

Curtis @ 11/4/2017 9:07

Can't say I'm surprised that Vlady showed up and continued throwing shade mine and Herm's way

Of course you aren't, since you've defended him, defended your own defense when challenged, then tried to throw another distraction by shooting it my way. If I had proof I'd really go after you, but all I have is Herm's muddled mess and your WIFOM. If I wasn't pretty sure timmah was town now given Cherry's Wikey targeting I'd think you had a connection there as well, because there always seems to be a new 'distraction' whenever certain people have been focused on.