jamie ♂ @ 23/3/2017 6:55

Edgardo blindside

This is in my top 3. So, so good.
Phillip going out in Caramoan is fun (though not played the best in my opinion)
Ozzy vote out in Micro with idol
Jason's vote out in Micro is also a super funny episode
Jeremy and Kelly vote cancel was a good joice

Shadow @ 23/3/2017 8:27

Sarah voted out in Cagayan is my number one Parvati and her two idols to take out JT Russell gives Parvati his idol and Tyson votes himself out Jessica draws the rock in millenials vs gen x Malcolm leaves game changers after a tribal of whispering (the to talk made that so much fun ) Others that I thought of after those 5; Ozzy blindside in micronesia Natalie gives her idol to Jaclyn to idol out Baylor Debbie leaves Kaoh Rong because of idol paranoia Phillip Idoled in fvf

Didn't see this yet. This is a good list.

Dylan @ 24/3/2017 15:33

I was going to add Matt's second blindside in RI good job Curt. Some other good ones not necessarily top 5: John Carroll's boot in Marquesas Paschal and the original rock draw Carl and Lindsey in the trivia face off. Erik giving up his necklace Amanda's surprise idol James leaving with two idols Jeff Kent's boot was pretty crazy You guys seem to have the more recent ones down. I think Sarah's boot would be my fav though.

What I loved about the Amanda idol was that we didn't even know if she had it as viewers because they never showed her finding it. Honestly, I'd prefer they do this a lot of the time. But most times the idol plays into a personal story.

Also because the whole idol being played is a huge part of how that tribal went down. At least I think. I haven't seen the episode yet. Going to go watch once I get home. Still traveling.

Lastly I'm super bummed this thread wasn't titled "Top 5 baby". And you call yourself a Tony fan, Curtis? Smh

Yeah, if I wasn't a fan of Jay before, his exit definitely made me one. That's how I would hope to go out of the game, but God knows I wouldn't.

John is a washed-out survivor has been. I hope he never returns.

Ugh. It's sad to think that if Penner didn't screw up that Kent vote that maybe he might have made it to the end if he didn't put his foot in his mouth.

Then again, he was fine if he would have just went with Lisa and Skupin.

Curtis @ 28/3/2017 18:25

Oh man I forgot about Rob C and the outcasts flipping on Alex DAMNNN that might replace Erik giving up Immunity. That's my favorite flip of all time

Even though I didn't enjoy what happened as a result, Matt throwing that final challenge and letting Rob go after he taught him everything was kind of ironic.

Also Penner not voting the right person leading to Kent getting voted out

Production casting Melissa McNulty

To throwboack to worst moves:


1. Erik giving up Immunity
2. JT's letter to Russell with idol that eventually sent him packing where he otherwise may have been in the finale
3. Lex and Kathy keeping Amber for Rob in All Stars
4. Tyson voting himself out
5. Brandon voting out Kelly instead of Lex in Africa

Top 5 winners:

Kim
Yul
JT
Todd
and I guess I would put Jeremy here?

Curtis @ 7/4/2017 14:33

Jeremy is for sure top five to me. I have no idea how people let him get to the end. Tasha and Spencer are fairly worthy FTC opponents too (maybe the most well rounded FTC f3 ever?) and for him to get all 10 votes against them is super impressive

One insight thing that I learned that they cut out is I guess Kimmi went OFF on Spencer in the FTC and made him cry (if I heard correctly) saying how he was a terrible role model and she hopes her boys never grow up to be like him.

I dunno, but after the game, Spencer had to go to therapy and stuff because the game killed him so bad mentally. But I don't think Spencer was well liked by the Jury and Tasha was definitely not well liked by many.

I would put up an argument for Earl, Boston Rob, and Hatch. Hatch is a tough one though, but he clearly established the game and pioneered so many things.

On various days I would switch those guys in and out. A lot of the women winners I feel played strong games toward the end but laid low at the beginning.