I am going to assume lamp didn't give anything out on N1 as not to put something in the hands of scum. A lot of restraint for a game where who knows when you are even allowed to submit an action but also classic lamps

(in before I finish catching up on these 4 pages and someone has already claimed and used the daykill)

Ok good I caught up

If there was a 6 person mafia team

6 mafia and 1 sk = 35% scum which isn't unreasonable

Then we are at lylo and lynching a SK wins the game for mafia. I am concerned that this is a gambit by scum star.

What role besides role cop which is a mafia role would be told someone's role exactly? Whether it's true or not this looks bad for star

Moose @ 7/8/2021 19:07

What did you think Rod

I have an inclination to lynch Stargate and a strong craving for hibachi

After the D1 317 stuff, and then the 317 accusation on d2. Anyone who didn't vote one of them yesterday is sus and anyone who didn't vote 317 is on my lynch list. Congrats Curtis and Nav, you are the only 2 that I trust

Me Curtis and Nav have to work together to fight crime. How do we think this is gonna go?

TheNavneet @ 7/8/2021 19:14

Rodney @ 7/8/2021 15:12 Me Curtis and Nav have to work together to fight crime. How do we think this is gonna go? oh im 85% sure ur scum but Starjug and Herm take precedence over u

Off to a strong start

Curtis @ 7/8/2021 19:15

Hey Ahoda you wanna help us mop up tonight?

If we leave Stargate alive I'm sure hodie will gladly do some mopping

Spin @ 7/8/2021 19:39

Rodney @ 7/8/2021 18:07 If there was a 6 person mafia team 6 mafia and 1 sk = 35% scum which isn't unreasonable Then we are at lylo and lynching a SK wins the game for mafia. I am concerned that this is a gambit by scum star. What role besides role cop which is a mafia role would be told someone's role exactly? Whether it's true or not this looks bad for star Explain how we are at lylo in that scenario? We killed im317, meaning at best (in your scenario) there are 5 mafia left. Even if we lynch SK today, it'd likely be 5v7 going into the night. Unless you think they can kill multiple people, I don't see it.

There's been 2-3 kills every night so this is not unreasonable

Ok so I got me Nav curt town read and I got Ahoda and star on the scum side and then everyone in the middle is just this big amorphous blob. Time to attempt to sort them out

BETTER
8. Spin present and trying
14. Moose present and trying

11. farlig
16. Timmah
20. Mittens
15. Havo

9. Jay been scum reading on vibes since d1
13. Herm trash voting record
WORSE

The middle 4 are tough but what they all have in common is I really hate their votes yesterday. Timmah looks the best for at least voting for Jay when Jay was actually a real option but mittens was on the mislynch train and the other two threw their votes. I can't even say Timmah looks good until I know jays alignment. Rough stuff.

Spin threw his vote too and moose didn't vote

A small positive is we'll have at least two town confirmated claims in vig and switch.

Anyone claiming even deeper backups to the switch I'm gonna have a hard time believing

TheNavneet @ 7/8/2021 20:11

if Rodney is town then Timmah and Havo are likely scum

Could I have more detail on this one please? Based on this I should be able to deduce both are scum and I'd like to know why

Stargate @ 8/8/2021 4:56

I don't know if Rodney is trying to be obtuse on purpose to keep discussion alive or because he's mafia or backup serial killer and doesn't want to lose ahoda. Yesterday 317 made a random comment about Penner being scum and Rodney voted for Penner and took it to the bank without even hearing his reason. Even asked if it was night info and assuming it was wanted Penner dead. Today, with info presented immediately, he's coming up with every excuse in the book not to see ahoda lynched. Feels very scummy to me. I'll be crystal clear. Ahoda's alignment is Serial Killer.

Lot of mental gymnastics in this post. I was clear yesterday that I thought either Penner or 317 was scum. Now why don't you take a look at where my vote was when it mattered before you try calling one of the 3 people in the whole game who got it right scummy