I stick by my former assessment of Malion

TLG lynched Greenday way before Rob revealed making him look pretty good (I know he unlynched but meeeeh)

##lynch Malion

Also Jeff is looking more likely to be anti town with two kills this night.

Rob is pretty much confirmed as town.

Rest are MEH MEH

LSFissue @ 18/2/2013 21:52

because ari is cool

Thats right

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 18/2/2013 22:59

I am still a bit wary on a jeff lynch, but the fact that he has absolutely nothing at all to say makes me lean a bit towards stinging him up by the neck. I'll give him a chance for now though. In the meanwhile ##lynch Vernon For just jumping around on various random trains. If we've all decided that metagaming is all the rage today, when Vernon is scum he tends to just dick around and lynch randomly because hurrr hurrr hurrr joaks. When he's town, he actually sticks to his guns on his apparently random lynches. Lynching Greenday round 1 could have just been an attemptto deflect that they were on the same side (or because he forgot they were scummates, which happens). I'd like to see the people who haven't actually contributed any thoughts to start though. Grim, LSFissue (I don't care if you're new, Alex, you play epicmafia enough to know how this works), Dylan, Justin and Jeff, I'm looking at you guys!

Wut? Wut? Wut?

Why lynch the guy that was trying to lynch Greenday before Rob claimed? You REALLY REALLY think Vernon is the mastermind behind some mafia plan that would make him look good? I dont think so. Makes me kinda think you are scum trying to vote off some easy vernon. SURE he is trigger happy and pretty aggressive and silly but I really dont think he would hatch the plan you are accusing him of.

Malion is being cringey as fuck. I smell mafia on him all the way to snowland. DR smells a lot like mafia with that lynch vote aswell. Anyone remember that DR train that suddenly headed for Panda day 1? Both Malion and Greenday where on that.....

Curtis @ 19/2/2013 7:11

Grimapple @ 18/2/2013 16:26 Oh shit. First reaction to two townie's dying during the night Remind anyone of old mafia? That was one of the first really common tells that I noticed among scum. The new day goes up, a few townies or a town power role dies, and the guilty people always go, "AW DAMN! Fuuuuuck! I'm pissed that those townies died, because I MYSELF am town!" Maybe a slight exaggeration but you get the point. I had noticed that post earlier and it stuck in my head. It might seem like a silly reason to most and I'd get it if people view it that way. But it just seems really fake to me. Besides that, Grim has done nothing but sit back, watch, and comment every so often on nothing that relates. I don't like when that slips by to the end completely unnoticed and I don't want it to happen here

Malion on day 2 said that it was "unfortunate" that Panda was town. He also talked about Boc / henry today. Dum dum dum!

Im also less confident on DR right now if the Neighbor story is true. I still think Malion is acting fishy. Vernon is acting like he always does, I still think that if Vernon really had a plan to make himself look better by lynching Greenday (how could he know he would survive longer than Greenday?) he wouldnt have pussied out as soon as it got momentum. Really seems like paranoid town Vernon not trying to give mafia an easy lynch....

Curtis @ 19/2/2013 9:13

Drrr I realize when you see this and realize that your argument about me is void due to some of us misreading your post, you'll try to say 'well i have other arguments that you didn't respond to'. My answer before you say it is that I think your arguments are stupid, frankly. All of your arguments against ME are based off of reasons why I don't trust you or don't like your arguments You think I'm shady for telling you not to get worked up, for not agreeing with your argument based almost entirely on metagaming, and for not wanting to follow your lead because you've been extremely suspicious to many of us since Day 1. You' say that I've been inconsistent and have played all these cards against you, but that really just proves that there are quite a few arguments against you. I can't even choose one!

Funnily enough the people DR thinks are scum are the only people alive who have tried to lynch her

Dr. Fröken Drrr @ 19/2/2013 10:11

AND while I'm still up, I forgot you lynched me at all, Ari. I'm suspicious of you because you tried to use Rito lynch voting against greenday before Rob ever claimed as evidence of his good standing. But there were no grounds to vote him. It was a useless joke vote that's not being heralded as evidence that he was good and town because he wouldn't vote against a scum mate, even though he jumped from the wagon once the situation turned serious and tried to switch it

I lynched you day 1

Who do you think we should string up Wikey?

I reeeeaaallly dont see this Rito lynch, but each to his own I guess...

Korr @ 19/2/2013 14:56

#lynch: Rito

-.-

Korr change into something loud mouthy

Tom Brady @ 19/2/2013 18:42

Malion What exactly is the good of a self-ousted bulletproof town anyway? Nobody would target them. Though I remember someone saying it was a one-shot I could just be talking out my ass though. An ousted bulletproof townie is useless if it is a one shot deal...but if not they would be important towards the end of a game if it was coming down to the wire. The only reason Jeff would claim to be a one time BP if he is actually a full BP is to attract more attacks. But why would the mafia target a vanilla? Curtis According to him we would be losing a one time BP townie and now a vanilla BP, but he could be lying and could be the doctor or a full BP What are your thoughts on Drrr? If Jeff was the doctor and protected himself night 1 then :| It turned out to be a good move if so, but I find it hard to believe that anyone would protect themselves after been that inactive. I think DR is a bit too insistent to lynch Rito. She had me convinced about him too but really there is only one scummy thing he did and that was jump off the Greenday train.

I dont think there has been a single doctor that hasnt protected himself on night 1 (given that he could)

Does anyone seriously believe Jeff is mafia with the amount of split votes?

Id say its between town and sk now

Leaffan20 @ 19/2/2013 21:06

Anyways when i die, you should take a look at Mal, I'm pretty sure he's scum just based off his posts, anyone else should at least scan or check him out.

Can we now lynch someone who actually has the chance of being scum?

His posts smell of mafia more like