Hello. I'm going to rate everything before reading this thread so I'm not swayed by anything.

Dyl - 2? A very delicious looking cake. I don't understand the falling cherry. Unless it's just to show there are a LOT of cherries. I dunno. Cake is universally regarded as very tasty.

Steph - 6. An old sock under the bed is innocent enough. Moving around is creepy but not necessarily alarming as a literal creature under the bed.

Boc - Solid 5. It's literally a milk carton monster!

Herm - 9. This is a lizard easily mistaken for a human.

Spin - Uh.... 4? This is all perspective. A regular day at work is fine for me. I'd rather be off obviously. But nothing bad happening leads to usually a pretty good day. Which puts it at more good than not.

Rodney - Uh.... 7? Pretty alarming situation but there's definitely more extreme out there.

Hmmm.

I'm not opposed to raising Boc's but I think the higher answers are wrong. The entire milk carton is still intact so I definitely think it's more towards the middle. This drawing reminds me a lot of the wizard/guitar example picture.

Maybe a 6 or maaaaybe a 7 but nothing higher.

Thoughts?

Oh I didn't notice the shirt and tie on the lizard so I'll knock Herm's down to a 7, maybe 8.

Going to go ahead and lock in a 6 for Boc.