Oh. Paul's role didn't work?

Curtis @ 25/11/2018 2:56

FOS on those who were so quick to shut down Jackie’s claim. That was goofy

Arguing the semantics of a role name always seems to be a lazy but surefire scum tactic. Of course, I only saw her isolated posts and not those around her casting doubt. That will include clicking through pages... yuck.

Semantics probably wasn't the right word, or at least it doesn't feel like it now that I've published it for the world to see.

Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 3:06

Hey Zersch hows it going man

Happy the holidays are over (for now) - yourself?

Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 3:10

Zersch @ 24/11/2018 23:09 Sebclops @ 25/11/2018 3:06 Hey Zersch hows it going man Happy the holidays are over (for now) - yourself? HAPPY the holidays are over??? Scum!

It's true, I've decided to be a Grinch this year.

Now I need to know one thing from you... do you walk with Elias?

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 3:14

Right now, I'm most suspicious of Curtis, Timmah, Josh and Zersch. For these reasons: Curtis - seemed to avoid really throwing doubt on 317 until his claim, before that he was pushing for other inactives. Josh - was the fourth vote on 317 so that could put him in a good light, but he could also have been doing that for town cred. Also, the little back and forth between 317 where he said Josh was "throwing him utb" seemed a bit staged. Timmah - said all the right things about who looked townish, made what seemed like a passing comment about 317 but didn't really seem to commit to anything until he was kind of "forced to" after 317 claimed. Zersch - just his absenteeism yesterday but he's here now so yay! Kat and Wikey are giving me vibes but Kat has posted so little and Wikey is hard to read since he does f around a lot.

I had to observe Black Friday from sun up to sun down, it's a very important day for me.

You're basically losing money if you're not spending it.

Hoping Shadow forgot to post the Banshee alert because he wanted to go to sleep and we will get it tomorrow sometime. Would Paul really get blocked and killed?

Shadow @ 25/11/2018 3:26

Mod note: banshee role only works if he’s alive to scream it

Thank you for the clarification. I retract my celebration of your death Paul, my bad.

I'm about to bite into a melatonin like it's cold war cyanide tablet and I'm a prisoner of war.

Good after morning~

Christian @ 25/11/2018 13:06

Ahoda @ 25/11/2018 11:38 Spider @ 25/11/2018 2:58 So much happened in the last 5-10 minutes at the end of D2. I felt like I was getting whiplash reading it all. My read of Jackie was off (sorry Jackie). We're losing too many town at night. This post pings the scumdar but could also be newb post as well for the entirety of this game, I'm looking at Spider as a newb. The end of day did get a little crazy.

The newb thing worked super well for Moose in her first game here, back in 1974.

Curtis @ 25/11/2018 13:40

itsbrianyay @ 25/11/2018 12:12 Curtis @ 25/11/2018 11:28 itsbrianyay @ 25/11/2018 11:21 Curtis @ 25/11/2018 11:09 itsbrianyay @ 25/11/2018 11:00 Come at me bro I’m hoping the Vig just comes at you tbh They are welcome to try I am difficult to kill ##Lynch Brian Your pathetic votes mean nothing to me for I am inexplicably difficult to lynch as well Uhh Huh. This is awkward

So if I'm reading this right, we have two people who seem to be claiming lynch-avoidant roles here, and a player that can force two people into being the lynch targets. Maybe two lynch-proof roles would be thrown in for Town to serve as a possible dead draw for a Mafia version of what Nav is claiming? Or somebody's a fibbin'.

Buffeminist @ 25/11/2018 15:06

^^looks staged in retrospect

It really does. But I can't help but find it cute that 317 claimed to be operating under the assumption that he and Josh "had a thing".

Talk about OTP material.

Jamie's claim was the voting thing right? What were the stipulations on him?

J-A-M-I-E @ 25/11/2018 15:31

Primate I will say that is a huge let down for this thing on Rose, felt like you had something actually useful. It was what made me think you could be town but it seems like you are just middle of the road and could go either way. Timmah and Josh are probably my biggest scum reads right now and any of the lower lurkers (Wikey, Kat, Lamps). Undecided on a lot of people. Town vibes on Herm, Buffy, Spider, Shawn. Townish vibes on Nav but Buffy does have a good point on the IM317/Nav stuff, I didn't think much of it at the time. I want Christian and TIB to both be town and I usually have blinders when it comes to them which means they are probably scum. If I didn't mention you it's because I am not pulled either way. or I forgot you

Town vibes on Shawn?

I felt like Curtis was claiming Mayor. Or an X-Menified version of the role.