I like it for the aforementioned reason of it being easier to mark off old votes on a vote count. But that's about the only reason. A new lynch cast by a player could just come with an understood ##Unlynch.

That it could keep a potential situation from shifting if someone voted near the end of the day but forgot to unlynch first is kind of silly. Not sure if that's ever happened, but it could, I guess.

Buffy's very reasonable drawing up above is really making me lean towards "get rid of it".

Just turn them off completely imo.