I don't know why but something still doesn't sit right with me about Greenday. Day 1 he lynched Boc and it was mainly ust because Boc was against Greenday, it was very defensive. Then he lynched Drr who is looking pretty town at the moment if Perry isn't lying but I doubt they would make that big of a risk this early in the game and lie about that so she seems town for now. Then he just randomly joins the easy Jordan train and says "Sounds like a plan I guess"

Also his claim and his role is very wishy washy it seems like he just got himself trapped and is trying to fight out of it.

##lynch: Greenday

Tricks @ 15/4/2014 16:38

Also, hi? Anything to say about the first ten pages of the day?

Are you talking to me?


I don't even entirely understand the suspicions on both Herm and Brian. I think there are a few posts that they have made the look kind of scummy but most people have. I need to read the reasoning more before I think about them two first.

Also someone I found scummy is Ari. His lynch on Curtis and whoever else lynched Curtis that day as well but Ari specifically because didn't he call other people out on lynching Curtis even though he did as well.

Tricks @ 15/4/2014 16:34

I'm going to point out again that Perry being town wouldn't make Rose town.

I'm not putting this aside but for now there's nothing there to know for sure what's going on with them two as in are they both town both Mafia 1 town or 1 mafia. But for now I see hem as both town which makes my suspicions for Greenday more likely true. His lynches on day 1 just don't sit well with me as well as his weird claim.

Greendayger @ 15/4/2014 19:52

Shawn @ 15/4/2014 16:32 I don't know why but something still doesn't sit right with me about Greenday. Day 1 he lynched Boc and it was mainly just because Boc was against Greenday, it was very defensive. Then he lynched Drr who is looking pretty town at the moment if Perry isn't lying but I doubt they would make that big of a risk this early in the game and lie about that so she seems town for now. Then he just randomly joins the easy Jordan train and says "Sounds like a plan I guess" alol in no way shape or form is drr cleared. FoS on this post because it almost seems like trying to hard to start this revisionist history for scum reasons. I'm still not sold on drr at ALL.

I never said Drr was cleared. I said she was looking town at the moment. She isn't cleared at all but I think she is looking better then some people. I later already made a post about how she was not cleared

Buffy @ 15/4/2014 20:07

Who'd you vote for again, Shawn?

Greenday but wiling to change. I don't trust Herm's role

Vernon of 2014 @ 15/4/2014 20:26

Haven't had time to read the thread at all today. It's my last day at work and I am about to leave for the Clippers game. Hopefully I am not receiving votes. Anyway, I reallllllly reallllllly say we vote for Herm today. That name has been coming up everywhere and I do believe they are scum. It will also make it much easier to create cases afterwards on others based on the result. I also listed my other suspects earlier. See ya.

say hi to Doc for me